Solving time : 27 minutes with one phone call distraction. I found this the hardest of the week so far, grinding to a halt with 9, 17, 16 and 23 unfilled. The break for a phone call helped, but there was still a good couple of minutes staring at 23 wondering what it was that I could miss on such a short word. There were a few sneaky traps laid, all of which I managed to fall into. After writing the blog, I realised there’s a bit of a general knowledge here and many proper nouns making parts of the clues, so I was probably lucky to get through.
Across |
1 |
BRAHMS: BAR* and then HMS (pinafore) |
4 |
S,COWLING: From the definition, I thought COWLING sounded like a contender, I didn’t know it meant the cap piece that goes over an engine
|
10 |
REHYDRATE: (HARDY TREE)* – anyone else on autopilot write in DEHYRDRATE? |
12 |
SIR ISAAC NEWTON: nice wordplay here – SIRIUS(star) without the U, A (article), ACNE (spots), WONT* |
14 |
(l)IMPLY |
16 |
COWARDICE: WAR entered in COD (fake – definition #4 in Chambers), ICE |
20 |
B,LESS: like the surface |
21 |
SECOND WORLD WAR: got this from the definition before seeing the wordplay – SECOND(back), WORLD(the Earth), WAR (RAW reversed) |
25 |
MAORI: A in MORI – I got this from definition, had not heard of the research firm |
26 |
ON THIN ICE: January is (m)ONTH 1 |
28 |
IN,VERT: I thought I’d check up VERT in Chambers too, having for a long time presumed that everyone knew it was French for “green”. But it’s got several other meanings, including a green bar in heraldry. You learn something every month |
|
Down |
1 |
BURNS NIGHT: second part is THING* – a holiday on January 25 to celebrate Robert Burns |
2 |
ABHOR: H in A BOR(n) and a well-hidden definition |
3 |
MO,DEST(in)Y: tricky wordplay, but should be easy to get from the definition |
7 |
IMPROVISE: IS in 1,M,PROVE(show) – I liked using show at the end of the clue |
8 |
GUY’S: sounds like GUISE, didn’t know the hospital, but wordplay and checking letters generous |
9 |
DAMASCUS: CU in AMASS with D at the top (van) |
13 |
SEA SERPENT: EASE,R in SPENT |
15 |
PADDED OUT: ADDED in POUT(bib) – yes, I fell for it and wrote in PADDED BRA thinking it was a cryptic definition |
17 |
WEYMOUTH: M in WE YOUTH – another new place. |
19 |
OX,ON,IAN |
20 |
BULL,I,ON: BULL being the city optimist at the stock exchange |
23 |
WAIVE: VIA (pass) reversed in W,E (bridge partners) and an &lit clue Edit: or not… I messed the wordplay up, it’s A in WIVE(s), thanks to many commenters
|
24 |
O.M,I.T: acronyms with acronyms! |
ANTISTES / ANTSIEST / INSTATES / NASTIEST / SATINETS/ TITANESS
(I’m keeping a whole-word anagram file if anyone wants it.)
So we shall surely see one of these again. Is 6dn a double def or a cryptic def?
Edited at 2009-08-13 08:40 am (UTC)
WIVE(s)round A.
I too went for w(a)ive[s] rather than w(aiv)e in 23 – maybe the setter will stop in an tell us which was intended. Nice to have ‘bra’ not clued as ‘supporter’, and the ‘HMS’ half was quite clever. I had head of Guy’s, but thought ‘titaness’ was a bit lame.
I have to admit, I couldn’t figure out the cryptic for ‘Sir Isaac Newton’ at all, and was very dull getting it from the literal, thinking first of 19th and 20th century scientists who nearly fit.
The one piece of general knowledge I didn’t have was ‘MORI’, so 25 was just a guess eventually confirmed by the checking letters.
There were many great clues, but I really appreciated the ‘cod ice’ in 16, so that’s my COD!
9D Why is “in the van” at the top?
19D: Why might an Oxonian’s cause be lost?
perhaps I should get up earlier while the crossword club login is still working.
This is twice within a couple of weeks, I do hope they’re not going back to their bad old ways.
Rupert Murdoch has, of course, floated the idea of charging for all his newspapers’ online content – if the Crossword Club is any guide, the experiment will not be a success…
I must admit that at least 10 of them went in without fully understanding the reasoning. Indeed when I first considered SIR ISAAC NEWTON at 12ac, before I had a single checking letter, I couldn’t see any connection with the clue other than “scientist” and (3,5,6). I enjoyed working out most of the wordplay after completing the puzzle as there was some good stuff here, but I still don’t understand the “lost cause” at 19dn.
I thought the inclusion of two GUYs in the NE was a bit weak. And does OMIT = “leave”? I can’t think of a context where it doesn’t mean “leave out” but perhaps someone can enlighten me as I don’t have the dictionaries to hand at the moment.
Wordplays for 2 and 15 both took a while to spot, and I didn’t gamble on these without understanding them. Tickled a bit by the juxtaposition of Damascus and Weymouth. Agree that 23D is W(A)IVE(s) – via is a preposition so cannot be defined by ‘pass’, which is a noun or adjective.
VIA could be clued as “Roman Road” or similar, as we’d then be in the realm of “general knowledge” rather than “dictionary definitions”.
*I think Chambers can be appealed to in exceptional circumstances: e.g. meanings of a word or phrase so common that COED and Collins seem obviously deficient.
Edited at 2009-08-13 11:26 am (UTC)
Tom B.
There was a higher than average number of definitions that were phases, which always makes things more difficult: “in danger of soaking”, “how confessor comes”, “not bravery either”. “is his cause lost?” This latter totally lost me but fortunately Steer is and old friend for Ox.
The last time Sir Isaac turned up, I noted that he was the only entry under Scientist in my crossword database. If I had trusted my own research I could have got started quicker.
Waive is unsatisfactory whatever way you look at it. Via can be a noun, meaning way or road, usually found in phrases such as Via Dolorosa, so it could conceivably stretch to meaning pass. The problem with this solution is that the clue does not parse very well, the wordplay and definition overlap. The Wive(s) solution parses more satisfactorily but Wive(s) for partners shortly is just awful.
Judging from the times and comments today (George from 8 mins yesterday to 27 mins today being fairly representative) solvers found this much trickier but I finished in about an hour (fast for me) with no aids and only OXONIAN and POUT not understood before coming here.
Perhaps yesterday’s introduced me to a whole new level of inventiveness which experienced solvers have embraced?
I, too, quibblified ‘leave’ for OMIT, and I’m in the W(A)IVE(s) club.
First in CLEAN, last in OXONIAN.
COD 14a IMPLY, which I’m now going to start pronouncing to rhyme with ‘limply’. It’s the sort of thing I do anyway, once humiliating myself translating in Latin class by pronouncing Pericles to rhyme with ‘miracles’, which makes it a far better name in my view. And it was only through an equally embarrassing public correction (from a professor who clearly thought I was taking the p) that I discovered ’emeritus’ doesn’t more or less rhyme with ‘toncilitis’. I have a long and mostly painful track record of this stuff.
ABHOR was my last in, and I didn’t really understand it until I came here. But then I didn’t ponder it for long.
I don’t have a problem with 23, so long as it’s A in WIVE(s). I don’t understand what’s so awful about partners shortly being WIVE. Surely WIVES is a perfectly acceptable word for partners, and shortly is often used to mean ‘remove the last letter’.
COD 12, but lots of other good ones.
Although I found it easy, that was more to do with the design of the grid and my early entries, allowing me to enter answers from definitions only, without fully understanding the wordplay (notably 3, 7, 15, 16, 26), though I eventually worked out all except 15. I also entered DEHYDRATE instead of REHYDRATE at first.
Lots of good clues in this, such as 3, 7, 17, 26. I think I’d pick 7 as COD for it’s combination of neat surface and complex cryptic structure.
Mike and Fay
Information just seen elsewhere indicates that you may well need to clear your cookies for the site – I did so between my failed and successful attempts. In Firefox, this is: Tools > Options > Privacy > Show Cookies > select the “entertainment.timesonline.co.uk” folder > Remove Cookies (worth remembering how, as a cookie clear-out often does the job with Times club access trouble)
I really wish sites like Timesonline would have a service status page where techies could post fault reports and updates. It would save a lot of anger and frustration. I wasted nearly an hour of my life the other night, not for the first time, trying to work out what I was doing wrong. Technical problems I can appreciate. It’s the not knowing that’s infuriating.
If I then go to a link I keep in favorites for today’s cryptic (http://crosswordclub.timesonline.co.uk/crossword/print?type=1) it works just fine (and change that final 1 to a 2 if it is Saturday, 11 for Sunday, etc)
Last in ABHOR where the definition was nicely concealed. So these last two and 17 were my favourite clues
Sir Isaac is the Tiepolo of the scientific world and appears to be the only mathematician or scientist known to Times setters – read the clue and wrote in the answer. I didn’t fall for “dehydrate” probably because I write the anagram fodder out and then cross it off to verify the answer – usually essential in Mephisto it’s slower but more accurate than guessing!
I had “wive(s)” at 23D and hadn’t even seen the “via” possibility until I read George’s blog. I also query OMIT=leave. I think DAMASCUS is an excellent clue.
Tom B.
Mike and Fay