9:33. This was unusually easy for a Dean Mayer puzzle, as far as I was concerned anyway.
There’s been some discussion of the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon (also known as the frequency illusion) here lately, and the singer Mario LANZA is an example of that for me. I had never heard of him (or so I thought) until he cropped up a couple of times in crosswords, and then I encountered him several times in the real world shortly afterwards. In this case I’m pretty sure I had come across him before (he really was very famous in his day) but until I needed his name to solve crossword clues it had just never fixed itself in my mind. That’s how this phenomenon works of course.
How did you get on with this one?
Definitions are underlined, anagrams indicated like (THIS)*, anagram indicators like this.
Across | |
1 | Topless soldiers showing muscle |
QUAD – |
|
4 | Apt to supply answer? A blessing in disguise |
ASSIGNABLE – (A, A BLESSING)*. I thought at first that this definition was iffy, since something that is ASSIGNABLE is the supplyee, as it were, rather than the supplier. However an amount of food, say, can also be said to supply a population. | |
9 | Ignore gathering storm, and I will see gloom |
DISCOURAGEMENT – DISCOUNT (ignore) containing RAGE (storm), ME (I). | |
10 | One stands in for man or father |
PROGENITOR – PRO, GEN(I)T, OR. | |
11 | Please run through what you earn |
PRAY – P(R)AY. | |
12 | Among patients ahead |
ONWARD – two definitions, one very mildly cryptic if only in so far as ON and WARD aren’t separate in the answer. | |
14 | Hot needle applied to sponge |
HANGER-ON – H, ANGER, ON. | |
15 | Drop baby into bowl |
DIMINISH – DI(MINI)SH. | |
17 | One sending bill |
POSTER – DD. | |
18 | Weak cup of tea unfinished |
THIN – THIN |
|
19 | Bitter as wine that’s carried round |
ASTRINGENT – AS, T(RING)ENT. TENT being a type of wine found in crosswords, of course. | |
21 | Walk to the bar, OK? |
CONSTITUTIONAL – the bar in the second part of the clue is the legal variety, who might consider something acceptable if it’s in accordance with the (in the case of the UK unwritten but nonetheless extant) constitution. | |
23 | Park surrounded by water |
DROP ANCHOR – cryptic definition. | |
24 | Pot, or go to pot |
SINK – DD, the first definition a reference to billiards. |
Down | |
2 | Torn, but not as to the bottom |
UNDER – |
|
3 | Name doctor one is dating |
DESIGNATION – (ONE IS DATING)*. | |
4 | Decorated cherished houses close to town |
ADORNED – ADOR( |
|
5 | Colour in drawing? |
STRETCH THE TRUTH – CD. To ‘colour’ is to ‘misrepresent by distortion or exaggeration’ (ODO). I think that’s all there is to it, anyway, but I can’t shake the feeling I’m missing something here… | |
6 | Keen to call short cosmonaut |
GAGARIN – GAGA, RIN |
|
7 | One boards morning train |
AIM – A(I)M. | |
8 | Old singer has to go off, heading for Easter Island |
LANZAROTE – LANZA, ROT, E |
|
11 | PR people drop into shows |
PRESS-AGENTS – PRES(SAG)ENTS. | |
13 | Being beside oneself |
NEIGHBOUR – CD. | |
16 | Romance? It’s “other things” in Latin name |
ITALIAN – IT, ALIA, N. Being an example of a romance language. ALIA are the things in inter alia. Not to be confused with alios, which is garlicky mayonnaise. | |
17 | One’s sorry about old actor |
POITIER – P(O)ITIER. Sidney of that ilk. | |
20 | Polyvinyl, one stocking material |
NYLON – contained in ‘polyvinyl one’. | |
22 | Exhaust — it’s quiet |
SAP – SA (sex appeal, ‘it’), P. An opportunity for me to reiterate my request that SA/it be retired. |
I always struggle with Dean’s puzzles (he’s the prime suspect for the one that was my nemesis in the Final) but this was a decent challenge that only just took me out of my 20 minute comfort zone.
FOI PRAY
LOI THIN
COD DROP ANCHOR
TIME 22:54
Edited at 2018-11-18 10:00 am (UTC)
I liked this. COD: DESIGNATION for its nice surface.
“Away from chess, a recent Quick Cryptic crossword contained a rare phenomenon indeed: a cryptic clue yielding two genuinely valid answers that both fitted in the grid. The clue was:
Blue vehicle, turning over, last in rally (4)
And the pattern of crosschecking letters gave:
_A_Y
Can you find both words that fit the clue? You can check your answers in Rose Wild’s Feedback column, which covered the story.
David Parfitt
Puzzles Editor
puzzles@thetimes.co.uk “
Edited at 2018-11-18 02:12 pm (UTC)
Doubly puzzling
An indignant Hector Wood wrote: “Quick Cryptic 1210 contains an error, in my view. The answer to 3 Down should be ‘navy’, not ‘racy’ as you have it. Please tell me I am correct.”
This was an interesting one. David Parfitt, the Times games and puzzles editor, explains that Mr Wood has chanced on one of the very rare occasions when a cryptic clue can lead to two equally valid answers.
The clue was: Blue vehicle, turning over, last in rally (4).
Mr Wood’s parsing of the clue was: definition = Blue = navy; wordplay = van (vehicle) reversed + Y (last letter in rally).
Our parsing was: definition = Blue = racy (as in a blue movie or blue joke); wordplay = car (vehicle) reversed + Y (last letter in rally).
“For this situation to occur,” David says, “the definition, wordplay and pattern of crosschecked letters in the grid need to fit both possible answers, so it really is something that happens only once in a blue moon. It’s slightly more common to have one obvious answer and an alternative that is a bit of a stretch, but rare to have one that fits both answers as well as this.”
This, he says, is one of the most difficult “errors” to spot in editing a puzzle. “The editor’s only hope is if he happens to solve the clue with the answer that the setter didn’t intend, as he will then spot that his answer doesn’t match the one the setter specified. However, if he chooses the answer the setter intended, it is highly unlikely he will notice the alternative.”
We apologise for causing this cryptic confusion.
But I did not give up and in a couple of longish shifts on Monday I managed to finish it. It felt like the hardest puzzle I had ever completed (an odd concept but clear I hope).
FOI was Lanzarote which illustrates something abut age and GK. LOI was POITIER -and I remembered seeing him in “In the Heat of the Night”.
Problems were Stretch the Truth -could not parse- and the rather brilliant DROP ANCHOR (2 LOI). Press Agents seemed unfamiliar.
Anyway, a very enjoyable challenge. David
Having become used to the “lean” style of Dean and (to a slightly lesser extent) the other ST setters we find the Guardian’s more verbose clueing very difficult. We find the signals much harder to find.
The fact that there are many more setters in the G. doesn’t help either.
However we do enjoy the extra challenge of the Gs. The previous offerings were so easy that they would be write ins for you guys.
Jan Fralick and Tom McGuirk Toronto.