This started quickly and finished slow for me, with the left-hand side of the grid being completed before any significant incursion into the right-hand side. It took about 15 minutes, so for some reason was scoring about 50% harder on the Rotterometer scale than usual – I wonder how you all found it.
Some nice misdirections, plenty of anagrams, a sprinkling of double definitions, all perfect fare for the QC. Thanks to Tracy for an enjoyable puzzle.
Definitions are underlined, anagrams indicated by [square brackets] and deletions with {curly ones}
Across
1 I agree to pick up judge (4,4)
HEAR HEAR – To pick up is to HEAR, and to judge is to HEAR, and together they make the well-known exclamation of approval (I agree!) from the hearers of a speech
5 Sales campaign conceals dishonest scheme (4)
SCAM – Hidden word in {sale}S CAM{paign}
9 Daughter left for Channel port (5)
DOVER – D{aughter} and OVER (left) – my FOI (first one in)
10 Wiped out text, start to finish, about elected Conservative (7)
EXTINCT – take TEXT, move the first T to the end (start to finish) and insert IN (elected) C{onservative}
11 What may be extracted from first half of olives treated? (3)
OIL – anagram (indicated by treated) of [OLI]{ves} (first half). The whole clue can also work as the definition, making this a kind of &lit
12 Traditional in Harrow for example (3,6)
OLD SCHOOL – A kind of double definition. Harrow school was founded in 1572, although there is some evidence of a school on the site since 1243, which makes it pretty old – pre-America as we tend to say in our house!
13 Waste energy making jam (6)
SCRAPE – Waste equals SCRAP with E{nergy} to make the kind of jam that Billy Bunter used to get in to, rather than the preserve. My COD (clue of the day) for the misdirection
15 The last word I caught back in picture palace (6)
CINEMA – AMEN (the last word) with I C{aught} all reversed (back) – my LOI (last one in) for no discernible reason – it should have been easy
17 Embargo on developing a missile (9)
BOOMERANG – anagram, indicated by ‘developing’, of [EMBARGO ON]
19 Well-liked dad (3)
POP – double definition. I worried about the well-liked abbreviation of POPular, but my Chambers says it is OK
20 Beatles song with odd title starts to beguile everyone (3,2,2)
LET IT BE – anagram of [TITLE] indicated by ‘odd’, with (starts to) B{eguile} E{veryone}. Beguile is my WOD (word of the day)
21 Confused, sailing in the Mediterranean (2,3)
AT SEA – another double definition
22 Nimble undercover agent runs inside (4)
SPRY – undercover agent (SPY) with R{uns} inside
23 Surveillance post exposed (8)
STAKEOUT – STAKE (post) OUT (exposed)
Down
1 Ghastly house I’d renovated (7)
HIDEOUS – anagram, indicated by ‘renovated’, of [HOUSE I’D]
2 Moving van I left in smithy’s block (5)
ANVIL – another anagram, indicated by ‘moving’, of VAN I L{eft}
3 Edible type of mushroom, an overflowing supply (4,2,6)
HORN OF PLENTY – a double definition. HORN OF PLENTY is both a type of edible fungus and a cornucopia or abundant source of supply
4 Winning answer had to involve English (5)
AHEAD – A{nswer} with HAD involving E{nglish}
6 Forgive swindler swindled (7)
CONDONE – Swindler (CON) is himself swindled (DONE)
7 Perhaps gold award after change of heart (5)
METAL – Gold is an example of a metal. The award is a MEDAL experiencing a change of heart, i.e. substituting a T for the D to give the answer.
8 Carrying cloak, an item robber may wear (8,4)
STOCKING MASK – Carrying gives STOCKING, as in we are stocking a particular item, and to cloak is to MASK. A STOCKING MASK was de rigueur for all villains in the crime films that I grew up with.
14 Bird, duck in list (7)
ROOSTER – something of an old chestnut this one. Duck is a score of zero in cricket, indicated by O, which is inserted in ROSTER (list)
16 Stop after snake makes for pitch (7)
ASPHALT – The snake is an ASP and to stop is to HALT, and think pitch as in tar or, erm ASPHALT
17 Building Society initially keeps bad accounts (5)
BILLS – bad is ILL inserted in B{uilding} S{ociety} (initially)
18 Prevent a check pinning rook (5)
AVERT – the check is A VET (as in to vet a candidate), with R{ook} inserted
19 Quickly spilling drop of red sauce (5)
PESTO – Quickly is PRESTO, spilling (removing) the R{ed} to leave the Italian sauce made with basil, cheese, pine nuts and olive oil (as in 11 across)
Completed in under an hour so I’m happy!
Struggled with 10a, 15a, and 3d.
I was done in 9.09 so I would put this down as slightly harder.
LOI 10ac EXTINCT WOD BOOMERANG
IMO you Mr.Rotter are the pick of the QC bloggers at present.
I would suggest you upgrade to the 15×15 before too long.
horryd Shanghai
I’m not sure I am ready for the 15 x 15 yet, even if there were an opportunity. My average time is more like 40 minutes than the 10 or so I spend on the QC, and I’m sure I would feel enormous pressure if blogging that one – I have nothing but admiration for the guys and girls that do it already.
Thanks again
Edited at 2016-08-25 08:54 am (UTC)
Had to cheat on the mushroom, and don’t think I’d have got it if I’d stared at it all day. Nevertheless, a fair puzzle; some clues of which wouldn’t go amiss in the 15×15? What do others think?
Thanks for blog, Rotter, great as always.
This error led me to Medal at 7d (unlike the athletes who medalled at the Olympics).
Having looked hard at 4d I corrected my error and then finished it all off. I was unsure about the parsing of 7d, 18a and 8d so was happy to get all correct in about 30 minutes. Thanks blogger and setter. David
some lovely clues e,g, sweet girls with hidden power are knockouts (3,4) would make many QC players cod, including mine
however (after I checked the answers) some vocubulay way beyond mine, and some curious answers where the anagrind is part of the answer e.g. “seat” as the clue and “eats out” as the answer
And then are the complete mysteries eg “break, whether or not resistence is maintained” which i can,t parse even after I have not only the answer. but also the parsing
I have completed the 15×15 occasionally on holiday when I have a day or two to spare, but for now i think I´ll stick to the QC,
Edited at 2016-08-25 08:57 pm (UTC)
I’m just happy that I can now occasionally succeed with the easier 15×15 puzzles, and I will flag them as such when I stumble across one. Invariant
Also only guessed extinct (which then decided metal/medal) and had no idea of the parsing: much more devious than normal for the QC. Did anyone get it from the parsing? or did we all just bif it and maybe / maybe not work out the parsing later
No problema with the mushroom, but no real COD candidates either
Edited at 2016-08-25 07:11 pm (UTC)
Rita