Quite gentle from Izetti here, 12:22 for me, with a fair amount of time on the LOI, 10a, which needed 6 checkers.
I actually spotted the Nina in this puzzle, it’s in the definition for 8A.
Definitions underlined in bold italics, (Abc)* indicating anagram of Abc, (parentheses for synonyms), {curly brackets for deletions} and [] other indicators.
| Across | |
| 1 | Called off dance, sadly having little room inside (9) |
| CANCELLED – (DANCE)* inside CELL (little room)
I was sure “little room” was going to be LOO. For CANCELLED, the American rule is to double the ‘l’ if the last syllable is accented when you add the suffix -ing or -ed, but not if the first syllable is accented. The British rule is to always double the ‘l’. This explains most of the differences: traveled, canceled, fueled and so on. (Both sides of the pond double the ‘l’ in words like propelled where the stress is on the second syllable.) |
|
| 6 | Metal container (3) |
| TIN – Double def
Originally, all cans were ‘tin can’ because cans were lined with tin. The Brits took tin, the Americans took can for the short name. |
|
| 8 | Somehow get Nina something to fight disease (7) |
| ANTIGEN – (GET NINA)
ANTIGENS are substances that trigger an immune response, while antibodies are proteins produced by the body to neutralize or eliminate antigens. Essentially, antigens are the “invaders” and antibodies are the “defenders”. Not sure Izetti has this right, biochemists of the blog please elaborate. |
|
| 9 | Appeal first to cause damage (5) |
| CHARM – C{ause} + HARM (damage)
“first to” to indicate the initial letter seems a bit unnatural to me. |
|
| 10 | The last word in forecasts in difficult situations (12) |
| PREDICAMENTS – AMEN (the last word) in PREDICTS (forecasts)
This was my LOI, and only unpacked post-submission. |
|
| 12 | Harry is secret agent, very holy person (6) |
| MOLEST – MOLE (secret agent) + ST [saint] (very holy person)
As soon as I saw “Harry” I thought must be “Hal”, and forgot to go back and check if it might be the definition. How long before we see Harry=Spare? |
|
| 13 | Doesn’t move bits of wood (6) |
| STICKS – Double definition | |
| 16 | Church always needs top people who will encourage others? (12) |
| CHEERLEADERS – CH{urch} + EER [E’ER] (always) + LEADERS (top people)
Not a fan of those tiresome poetic abbreviations (called syncope) such as “o’er” or “e’er”. Come on, poets, it doesn’t fit, so chose a different word. Also “people” used twice here, is this a bug or a feature? |
|
| 19 | Excellent new form of oil, a dressing (5) |
| AIOLI – AI (A1=Excellent) + (OIL)* [new form of]
I always find this word tough to spell. A1 actually comes from the Lloyds classification of ships, where A1 was the best. I can now share this excellent cartoon about Julius Caesar playing Battleships: |
|
| 20 | Shake maiden overcome by huge drink (7) |
| TREMBLE – M{aiden} inside TREBLE (huge drink)
The ever reliable Fowler distinguished between triple which suggests three different things (triple jump, triple crown) and treble which suggests three of the same thing (treble 20, winning the treble, a “huge drink”). US English doesn’t seem to make this distinction. “Trebles all round” as they used to say in Private Eye. |
|
| 22 | Not all sleep in shelter (3) |
| LEE – {s}LEE{p}
I always get confused between LEA (meadow), LEE (shelter) and LEIGH (pretentious suffix on house names in the Home Counties) |
|
| 23 | Rage uncontrollably and provoke female relation (5-4) |
| GREAT-AUNT – (RAGE)* + TAUNT (provoke)
Collins has GRAND-AUNT as a possible alternative. Kind of word that probably crops up in Mephisto. |
|
| Down | |
| 1 | Pussy protecting old fur? (4) |
| COAT – CAT (pussy) contains O{ld} | |
| 2 | Normal sort of note (7) |
| NATURAL – Double Def
In Music if a note is neither sharp nor flat it is NATURAL, and has the sign ♮. (It’s a bit more complex than that, but close enough) |
|
| 3 | Work unit in Chester garden (3) |
| ERG – Hidden in Chester garden
The ERG is a unit of energy equal to 10−7 Joules, and is mainly used in astrophysics. An ERG is about the amount of work done by a fly performing a “press-up”, the leg-bending dip that brings its mouth to the surface on which it stands and back up. |
|
| 4 | Spreading calumny, losing millions is madness (6) |
| LUNACY – (CALU{M}NY)* [remove M{illions}]
The association of madness with the moon goes back to at least at least Pliny. But Pliny believed all sorts of weird stuff. It appears in the Bible (Matt 4:24), σεληνιάζομαι (seléniazomai) which is translated in the King James Version as “lunatick.” …they brought unto him all sick people that were taken with divers diseases and torments, and those which were possessed with devils, and those which were lunatick, and those that had the palsy; and he healed them The English 1871 and 1881 censuses included columns to identify “lunatics” alongside “imbeciles” and “idiots”. By 1901, the term “idiot” was replaced with “feeble-minded”. |
|
| 5 | Mac dieted wrongly — reduced by 10 per cent (9) |
| DECIMATED – (MAC DIETED)*
I’d say used to mean reduced by 10 per cent, and now actually means “devasted”, and is a word that launches a myriad of pedants, and yes myriad originally meant 10,000 but no-one has a pet peeve about that. |
|
| 6 | School term’s beginning with wet weather (5) |
| TRAIN – T{erm} + RAIN (wet weather)
“School” the verb, here. |
|
| 7 | Goddess arranged mise en scène originally (7) |
| NEMESIS – (MISE EN S{cene})*
NEMESIS was the spirit of divine retribution against those who succumb to hubris, the meaning is now extended to something like arch-enemy. mise-en-scène in cinematography refers to everything that appears before the camera—the sets, props, costumes, actors, and even the lighting. |
|
| 11 | Spotting some Parisian in tears (9) |
| DESCRYING – DES (Some Parisian) + CRYING (tears)
Most of my NHOs in crosswords are botanicals, composers, birds etc. Not often they are straight English verbs like this, and I can’t recall ever coming across it. I kept banging my head against “describing” and “decrying”. I’ve not read Janes Austen’s Emma, but there it is in Chapter 28: Miss Bates, passing near the window, descried Mr Knightley on horseback not far off. |
|
| 12 | Outside one church mum meets the Spanish saint (7) |
| MICHAEL – I(one) + CH{urch} contained inside MA (mum) + EL (“the” in Spanish)
To us English, St Michael is most famous not for being an archangel but for being in our pants, as a brand of Marks & Spencer. It was introduced by Simon Marks himself, but was retired in 2000.
|
|
| 14 | Vehicle I purchased — not half a beast! (7) |
| CARIBOU – CAR (Vehicle) + I + BOU{ght}(purchased)
I always find this “not half” business a bit odd. It just means half. |
|
| 15 | One insect or another that will die ultimately (6) |
| BEETLE – BEE (another insect) + {tha}T {wil}L {di}E
This type of clue uses the single word “insect” in both the wordplay and the definition. |
|
| 17 | Aloof, hiding head? Show feelings dramatically (5) |
| EMOTE – r{EMOTE} (Aloof) | |
| 18 | Garment in love story (4) |
| VEST – Hidden in love story | |
| 21 | Consume beef, say, sliced off on top (3) |
| EAT – m{EAT} (beef, say) | |


08:35. took quite a while to get going but mostly straightforward until the LOI, Descrying. nice puzzle, thanks both!
A quick-for-me solve in 9:31, and good to have Izetti back in ecclesiastical garb. Despite a fair amount of fat-fingering and inability to see the obvious, I didn’t get really stuck. Never heard of treble for a drink, that sounds pretty scary to me. It’s hard to choose a favorite today, I liked the very holy spy and the Spanish saint and PREDICAMENTS. Amen.
If you think DESCRY is out there, look out for “scry”.
Thanks to Izetti and Merlin, great blogging today. So glad to learn about the fly! Sorry you’ve never had the pleasure of getting to know the insufferable, lovable Emma.
11:57 for me
7:49
LOI BEETLE.
COD ERG. Nice to see that the CGS system of units has not yet been forgotten.
Thanks Izetti and Merlin
Tricky in parts, 11d and 17d we found difficult.
16:21
I was expecting a trip back into the SCC today with only 3 crossers in the first pass, so was pleasantly surprised at my time.
Second from LOI DESCRYING (NHO) led to a lengthy pause figuring out LOI MOLEST – I couldn’t get Harry Palmer out of my head from “Harry is secret agent”.
Also parsed BEETLE incorrectly thinking a beetle and death(watch) beetle were “one insect or another”. Upon reflection, not very bright of me.
Great blog Merlin – thanks, and thanks to Izetti
I’m not a biochemist but am a doctor who undertakes stem cell transplants and I can confirm that antigens definitely do not fight diseases. Antigens are cell surface proteins found on your own cells as well as invaders. The role of the immune system is to essentially determine ‘self from non self’. This is primarily done by recognition of foreign antigens.
However, in the spirit of the puzzle and that presumably 99% of people do not have an intimate working knowledge of the innate and adaptive immune system, I’d let it slide, though it did make me tut and shake my head. Great puzzle anyway!
Thanks for the detailed explanation, and I like your attitude about technical terms and crosswords! I often have trouble remembering the difference between an antibody and an antigen. “Antibody” sounds like an enemy but isn’t.
No prob! Yes it is quite confusing. It gets more confusing in that you can also have auto-antibodies where the antibody is directed towards your own antigens.
I think it was possible to tweak the clue a bit to make it more accurate but you’d lose the surface reading and possibly the wordplay might not work as well. I think it’s a fair clue for those who don’t have detailed knowledge and even with my knowledge it was straight forward as easy anagram and I kind of got what they meant!
I found this hard, resorting to use of the check button for the last few – so a DNF. Harry had me totally lost. Still enjoyable though.
Thanks Izetti, and to Merlin for a fascinating blog.
7:36. Quick today, no big hurdles.
Only hold up was descrying.
cod vest
As it is late I wasn’t going to comment but Merlin’s blog was so informative that it deserves acknowledgment.
Very nearly sub 20m but DESCRYING and MOLEST took me over the line to 21:12.
Thanks Izetti. I’ll probably regret this comment but I rather miss your harder QCs.
10 mins
Missed 15 x 15 by 2. Not good.
6:12, one day I’ll beat that 5 minute mark, but not today!
Oh dear, with the L from 2d I thought 12a has to be Harry PALMER (Michael Caine)with Palmer also being a pilgrim returning from the Holy Land. So close.