Straight down the middle, nothing too easy or hard.
12:10 for me, nothing too bad. 1D was my LOI, and it still doesn’t seem quite right. Thoughts?
Definitions underlined in bold , synonyms in (parentheses) (Abc)* indicating anagram of Abc, other wordplay in [square brackets] and deletions in {curly} brackets.
| Across | |
| 1 | Forged art, say, is wrong (6) |
| ASTRAY – (ART SAY)* [Forged]
This clue almost works both ways, with either “forged” or “is wrong” being anagram indicators. I think “is wrong” is better for the defintion, though. |
|
| 4 | Object in white, moonstone (4) |
| ITEM – Hidden in white moonstone
Of all the words beginning with m that Mara could have chosen, why “moonstone”? Sometimes setters choices are very odd. |
|
| 9 | Rodent caught with the newfangled mechanical device (7) |
| RATCHET – RAT (rodent) + C{aught} + (THE)* [newfangled] | |
| 10 | The blue canoe is new! (5) |
| OCEAN – (CANOE)* [is new]
“The blue” is more often the sky, but this quote from George Eliot has it both ways: Where one may float between blue and blue. |
|
| 11 | Fish netted by country working independently (9) |
| FREELANCE – EEL (fish) contained in FRANCE (country)
Originally referring to a mercenary in the Middle Ages, although no usage from before that great glamoriser of the chivalric time: Walter Scott in Ivanhoe. |
|
| 12 | Chestnut tree (3) |
| BAY – Double def
The first relates to colours of horses, where “chestnut” and “BAY” are used as nouns. My sources tell me they are not the same, the difference lies in the black areas such as the ears, mane, tail, and lower legs. Chestnut horses, on the other hand, lack any black hair, presenting a uniform coloration across their body. It goes on to say “For horse enthusiasts and professionals alike, understanding these differences is crucial.” |
|
| 13 | Engineer building tower, somewhat unfortunate if fell! (6) |
| EIFFEL – Hidden in “unfortunate if fel”
Sharper eyes than mine (thanks, Lindsay) point out that it’s not actually an anagram : (IF FELL)* [unfortunate]. |
|
| 15 | Confirm the correctness of a time trial (6) |
| ATTEST – A + T{ime} + TEST (trial) | |
| 17 | Punch chest (3) |
| BOX – Double def | |
| 18 | Ruin Ghana after moving from European country (9) |
| HUNGARIAN – (RUIN GHANA)* [after moving]
The “ruin” is the anagrist not the anagrind: see our Glossary if this makes no sense. |
|
| 21 | Vacate the French avenue (5) |
| LEAVE – LE (“the” in French) + AVE{nue} | |
| 22 | Male factor, a reddish colour (7) |
| MAGENTA – M{ale} + AGENT (factor) + A
“factor” for an agent or a representative is not so common, but this is the original meaning, for example the Lord would send his factor to collect rents. |
|
| 23 | Desire Shakespeare, say? (4) |
| WILL – Double Def | |
| 24 | Sorted out and put away (6) |
| STORED – (SORTED)* [out] | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Somewhat sweet, is it? (1,6) |
| A TRIFLE – Double def
I struggled with justifying the “A”. But its meaning of “somewhat” always includes an A. And then for the second part, an “a” is needed in the answer to the question “Sweet is it?”. |
|
| 2 | 19 things in the last edition, originally (5) |
| TITLE – First letters of “things in the last edition”
19 cross-references NAME below, hence TITLE. |
|
| 3 | Weakness and evil in Chelsea he condemned (8,4) |
| ACHILLES HEEL – ILL (evil) contained in (CHELSEA HE)* [condemned]
Although originally an ancient myth, only crops up in English in the early 19th century, notably by Samuel Taylor Coleridge. |
|
| 5 | Quaver from soprano captivating musician, initially (7) |
| TREMBLE – TREBLE (soprano) contains M{usician}
I expect ex-choristers (like me) to query this. Although soprano and treble both sing the top line of choral music, sopranos are always female. Although in choirs “Treble” seems to always refer to boys whose voice hasn’t broken, the word treble is used for any of the highest ranges (eg treble recorder, treble clef). So all sopranos are trebles (the reverse is not true), and in this clue that is what Mara needs. |
|
| 6 | Notes and coins one dropped in well! (5) |
| MONEY – ONE inside MY! (well!)
This is the exclamation of surprise. |
|
| 7 | School where sci-fi film is being shown? (4) |
| ETON – ET (sci-fi film) ON (is being shown)
Other schools are available. |
|
| 8 | Flat perhaps and neat, the last few yards (4,8) |
| HOME STRAIGHT – HOME (flat) + STRAIGHT (neat)
I blogged about HOME STRETCH last time, when the clue was RUN-IN. So I confidently entered it this time, but was a letter short. |
|
| 14 | Fix a lot with styling brush (7) |
| FOXTAIL – (FIX A LOT)* [with styling]
Actually made from soft, natural fibers like horsehair: name comes from its resemblance to a fox’s tail, both in shape and texture. The ones I saw on Amazon look just like the brush that goes with a Dustpan. |
|
| 16 | Student finally drank a dodgy mug of beer (7) |
| TANKARD – {studen}T + (DRANK)* [dodgy] + A
I looked this up and was surprised to see that it was a “drinking-vessel, formerly made of wooden staves and hooped”, just like a mini barrel (capacity 4 pints!) |
|
| 17 | Elbow bent under (5) |
| BELOW – (ELBOW)* [bent] | |
| 19 | Call chap up on phone, in the end (4) |
| NAME – NAM[=MAN (chap) reversed ] + phon{E} | |
| 20 | Private investigator neatly nailing eccentric rogue, on all fronts (5) |
| INNER – Initial letters [on all fronts] of “investigator neatly nailing eccentric rogue” | |
Gave in with 2 outstanding – Attest and Home Straight.
Thanks Mara and Merlin.
13:20, all very pleasant.
Thank you for the blog!
Late to the party but just wanted to say I really enjoyed that puzzle. Some great surfaces and fun solves.
I see others did it but I’m quite impressed I managed to anagram ‘if fell’ into EIFFEL and get a correct answer. Needed the blog to spot my mistake. I do like these idiot friendly clues.
A couple needed a think but nothing that took excessive time.
Liked OCEAN, HUNGARIAN, ETON (a penny drop moment) and the simplicity of WILL
19 minutes.
Struggled throughout and didn’t really get going.
Well over an hour for about 2/3 of the clues on 15 x 15. Another dissatisfying grind of a day. I’m not really up to the right level for the 15 x 15 because I lack the mental gymnastics required to tease out the clues.
Thanks for the blog.
I’m nowhere near the skill of you lot, but this is the very first puzzle I’ve finished on my OWN without checking here on the blog. A few guesses, but figured most of them out (some, after I put in the word). My time 55min 18 sec… but a WIN for me!