Still suffering from my QC withdrawal symptoms (if indeed they exist and are not simply dimwittedness symptoms – see last blog from me), although I do believe that the QCs are getting harder. Nevertheless, that is how I like them, so many thanks to Joker, who produced at least three clues here that stumped me for longer than usual and contributed to another 12-minute time for me. Great fun.
1A set the tone. It was my FOI, but not in the usual way. It did not come immediately to me, but with the above thoughts spinning round my head I spent several extra seconds thinking it through and rejecting the more obvious sorts of ‘tree’. What with my recent experience I was thinking “Surely a tree is just a tree – or is it? Ah yes, but how many different types of tree are there?”.
And so it went on. Yes, of course, there were plenty of the usual QC write-ins, but a good number of others that made me stop and think longer than usual. Whether justifiably or not I will discover when you all add your own comments. 12A held me up a long time, and my LOI was 17D, although looking back I can’t really see why it was that as it definitely seems easier in retrospect than some of the others. Difficult to choose a COD but I will go for 7D (even though this was one of the write-ins for me) because of the smooth surface and mechanism. 16A also deserves a mention for the same reasons although again I happened to be on the right wavelength for this.
The next time I do this I will be on holiday in Canada and the USA, so please expect nothing more from me than FOI, LOI, COD and a brief comment on ease or difficulty.
Definitions are underlined and everything else is explained as simply as I can just as I see it.
Across | |
1 | Old chestnut caught by a lot of another tree (6) |
CLICHE – C (‘caught’, as in the abbreviation for being ‘out’ by that method in Cricket) + LICHEe (‘a lot of’ another tree, viz LICHEE, the chinese tree from which cometh the fruit of the same name). These used to be a fairly inevitable dessert accompaniment to a Chinese meal back in the early 70s when they were exotic and new. Children and adolescents (as I was then) used to love them for their ghoulish resemblance in colour and presumed texture to human eyeballs. Interesting to see a step up in the obscurity of the type of tree that grows in QC crossword land, where we are more used to seeing ASHes, ELMs, YEWs and other more obvious (to home-grown eyeballs anyway) varieties. | |
4 | A quick look outside hotel for dustbin in New York (6) |
ASHCAN – A + SCAN (quick look) ‘outside’ H (hotel in most of the phonetic alphabets generally in use). | |
8 | Old wine they do fancy with very fixed views (4-2-3-4) |
DYED-IN-THE-WOOL – straight anagram (‘fancy’) of OLD WINE THEY DO. | |
10 | Insinuate plainly where son has gone (5) |
IMPLY – SIMPLY minus the S (‘when son has gone’). | |
11 | Silver mesh installed in second generator (7) |
MAGNETO – AG (silver, from the Periodic Table symbol Ag for argentum, meaning silver in Latin) + NET (mesh) ‘in’ MO (a second, as in “wait a mo(ment)”). | |
12 | Expensive retaining mine that’s very steep (11) |
PRECIPITOUS – PRECIOUS ‘retaining’ PIT (mine). | |
16 | Mean to assert seniority (7) |
AVERAGE – AVER (assert) + AGE (seniority). | |
17 | Certain about good rise (5) |
SURGE – SURE (certain) ‘about’ G (good). | |
18 | What’s immoral parking by local politician (4,9) |
VICE PRESIDENT – VICE (something immoral) + P (parking) + RESIDENT (local). | |
19 | Mounted equipment to limit noise (6) |
RIDING – RIG (equipment) ‘limiting’ DIN (noise). | |
20 | Cut sound made by detector (6) |
CENSOR – homophone for SENSOR (detector). |
Down | |
1 | Taxi driver has change of heart as driver’s assistant? (6) |
CADDIE – CABBIE (taxi driver) with his ‘heart’ (two central letters) changed gives CADDIE, cryptically an assistant to a ‘driver’, as a golfer hits many different types of shots, of which some are ‘drives’ (the first shots on the longer holes). Perhaps at this point I could quickly mention in passing the comment made on the ALBATROSS that appeared in the 15 x 15 the other day. I saw that the blogger, quite rightly in my view, queried the definition as being a ‘shot’ (as I remember it) and suggested rather that it was a series of shots. Well yes, that is normally how it is, because it is actually a score of 3 under the par for a hole. So the usual way of doing that (I say usual, but it is in fact an extremely rare occurrence, rarer in fact than a hole in one) is to finish a hole that is a par 5 in 2 shots. But another way of doing it would be to hit a hole in one on a par 4. And in that case the albatross would in fact be just a single shot.
While I am at it, perhaps I could blow the trumpet for my son (as he certainly would not do it for himself) who became a ‘scratch’ (0 handicap) golfer recently, and who hit an albatross once while playing with a friend and his brother and me. On the 565-yard par 5 17th at his local course he hit his drive what must have been about 320 yards, then stepped up and holed his 245-yard 3-wood second. As I said, that is rarer than a hole in one, and I was very privileged to have been there at the time as even just to witness an albatross is probably rarer than a hole in one! |
|
2 | Precede nine with XI in mix-up, being new to the job (13) |
INEXPERIENCED – straight anagram again (‘in mix-up’) of PRECEDE NINE + XI. | |
3 | Uncovered fire in dry grass is rather alarming (5) |
HAIRY – IR (‘uncovered’ fIRe) ‘in’ HAY (dry grass). | |
5 | Cunning dexterity of small and large rowing team (7) |
SLEIGHT – S (small) + L (large) + EIGHT (‘rowing team’). | |
6 | Shut parts of town as restricted area (5,8) |
CLOSE QUARTERS – CLOSE (shut) + QUARTERS (parts of town, probably heard more on the continent such as in French quartieres. Apologies for my French spelling as the blog keyboard doesn’t seem to know how to do a grave accent). | |
7 | Hold one in high position in Westminster (6) |
NELSON – cryptic definition. A NELSON (either HALF or FULL) is a ‘hold’ in wrestling. And of course there is a tall column somewhere in Westminster atop which stands a statue of Admiral Lord Horatio NELSON. | |
9 | Hunter, perhaps still following herb, reportedly (9) |
TIMEPIECE – double homophone (‘reportedly’) with PIECE (sounds like PEACE = STILL) ‘following’ TIME (sounds like THYME = HERB). Unusually in a QC I am finding myself feeling as though I ought to explain some defnitions as well. A hunter is a type of pocket watch. A ‘full’ hunter has a cover over the face, and a ‘half’ hunter has a hole in the cover so that you can see the time without having to open the cover, a distinct advantage when you are trying to HUNT on horseback, (hence the name) and would rather not have to distract your attention from the upcoming low tree branch in order to open the cover on your watch to find out when you should be home for your tea. [Definition underlining corrected – see comments.] | |
13 | Climber’s aid is a disadvantage round slope (7) |
CRAMPON – CON (diasadvantage, as in ‘pros and cons’) ’round’ RAMP (slope). Do I have to explain this definition as well? An attachment to a climbing boot to make climbing easier and less hazardous? | |
14 | Be undecided about India’s suspension of rights (6) |
WAIVER – WAVER (be undecided) ‘about’ I (India, again in phonetic alphabets, but also I think just as a straight abbreviation used for the country (similar to UK or USA)). | |
15 | Delicious drink? About time in local (6) |
NECTAR – C (about) + T (time) ‘in’ NEAR (local). | |
17 | Sleep’s upset on English lace? (5) |
SPIKE – KIP’S (sleep’s) ‘upset’ (upside down) ‘on’ E (English) in this down clue. Definition is LACE in the sense of to ‘SPIKE’ a drink, as in: “I later found out that she had spiked my tequila with Rohypnol, barbiturates and ayahuasca, which might have been why I felt a little unsteady on my feet”. Sorry, that was a completely gratuitous unscripted example of the use of the verb in question, but I just felt like signing off with a bang. |
Thank you astartedon for the detailed blog and Joker for the workout.
Edited at 2018-10-22 07:32 am (UTC)
Some toughies.
One of my problems was of my own making as I cannot have been concentrating when I wrote DYED-IN-THE-WOOD at 8ac which presented me with difficulties when solving 7dn.
I misparsed 1ac as C,LICHE{n} although wondered momentarily how ‘lichen’ could possibly be categorised as a tree.
Edited at 2018-10-22 08:18 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-10-22 09:21 am (UTC)
What a relief to find that others struggled with this, my goodness that was hard work in places. I too am a lifelong “lychee” merchant so like Jack and others was wondering how on earth lichen had a tree form when eventually I got 1ac. 1ac was the penultimate one in and 1dn the LOI, which is always somewhat dispiriting. Other ones I found really tough were RIDING (which I needed the blog to parse, thanks Don), HAIRY and CENSOR. Heavy lifting today!
Brilliantly readable blog though, thank you Don, and slightly grudging thanks to Joker for a serious wake up call this sunny Monday. Around 2.5 on the Kevometer.
Templar
Edited at 2018-10-22 10:31 am (UTC)
Thanks to the blogger, but to the setters can we not get back to some QC,s that are just that.
Thanks for the blog- at least I knew about the Hunter watch -we’ve got one that my mother-in-law used when out hunting side saddle in the ‘50’s.
On homophones: All I can say is, read carefully; there will (almost) always be one word that doesn’t fit the definition. Today’s example is really too dicey for the QC (and as I said, I dithered), but ‘cut sound’ made by SENSOR is a lot less likely than cut (CENSOR) being a sound made by ‘sensor’.
Edited at 2018-10-22 12:57 pm (UTC)
I don’t usually mind the tougher puzzles as they offer a good learning opportunity but I felt this was pushing the boundaries for a QC.
Excellent blog
I am normally on Joker’s wavelength; he had just changed the frequency a bit. I made life very difficult for myself at first, putting Cabbie at 1d,a wrong write-in; and Scary at 3d, ditto.
FOI was Crampon, about my only correct write-in. I made steady progress after that; the last three were 1a, 3d and 7d. I corrected Scary to Hairy and that gave me Cliche. It took me ages to think of Nelson, perhaps because I associate him with Trafalgar Square which is not Westminster in my brain, although it might be for the postman.
Just over 30 minutes in total . A very good puzzle I thought but demanding for beginners. David
You have to have seen these cluing techniques at least several times before to be able to work these levels of puzzles. The clever literals, in particular, may confuse many beginners, but are mild compared to what goes on in the more difficult puzzles.
Early this morning (very) I had prepared the blog so that all I had to do was hit ‘post’. I intended to come back and give it a read through AND to add in a comment about LICHEE before doing that, but then I got involved in some other tasks, during which I forgot that I had yet to finish the blog off. Then I realised I had forgotten about the blog altogether and that it was now quite late (about 8.20) so I went to try and post it… and realised I had accidentally closed my browser. So all I had time to do was to fire up the browser again and post the thing.
Had I had but all the world and time that I had planned for myself I would have gone through the draft again and I HOPE that I would have noticed my definition underlining error at 9D (pointed out by Kevin for which many thanks). But what I definitely would have done would have been to make a comment on LICHEE, something along the lines of the following:
From those days in the 70s I do remember noticing that LYCHEE was spelt with a ‘Y’, but one of the things I have learned from crosswords is that words of foreign origin often have at least one and sometimes several alternative spellings. After all, these words are usually made up by transliteration from the original foreign word, so that there is no ‘correct’ spelling and in the current example both of those are plausible spellings. The way the original transliterator would have spelled them depends much on how they sounded (was it L-EYE-CHEE or L-ITCH-EE?) when he or she heard them.
We keep seeing examples of this when through our historical connections we have got the sound of place names wrong. Thus the Indians have had to come back to us and say “Excuse me, but it doesn’t really sound like ‘BOMBAY’ the way we say It, It’s more like ‘MUMBAI’.” And the Chinese have had to do a similar thing with PEKING and BEIJING.
And I do remember a similar thing from my earliest encounter with crosswords. I must have been about 10 when our English teacher, as an end of term treat, let us off our proper lesson and told us all to have a go at compiling a crossword. Well, being a precocious brat at least in this department, I put a lot of effort into this and included my own crude form of misdirection in one clue deliberately to stump everyone: I included one clue to which the answer was PORAGE. Sure enough, nobody got it, and with glowing pride in my abstruse knowledge I revealed it to the class and the teacher. At which my pride turned to ear-burning embarrassment when he said “don’t be stupid, boy, that’s not how you spell PORRIDGE!”. I started trying to explain to him about my Scottish extraction (he was VERY English) and how I knew that this was an alternative spelling but to no avail. He would not listen. In the way of many teachers (certainly in those days) he knew he was ‘right’ and that was that.
Happy memories. I had forgotten about that episode until now.
Anyway, the lesson for all crossword solvers is that if ever you come across an answer that you are damned sure is right but it just doesn’t fit for some reason, then check if it is a word of foreign origin and it may well be the case that there is an alternative spelling lurking somewhere in the dictionary!
If it’s not lychee it’s sometimes litchi, but I’ve never seen the hybrid of the two before, even though it’s perfectly acceptable. I just about stopped myself from entering DIED in the wool, the sort of typo that’s so very easy to make.
There was a lot to like here (as a retired cabbie, I loved 1D), and 20A was a first rate clue.
Those of you who struggled shouldn’t feel daunted, because this was the equivalent of Olympic standard for the event !
Graham
Thanks all
John George
Tim
Thanks as ever to the blogger for explaining the mysteries – magneto, Nelson and the lichee tree.