I didn’t find this terribly hard, and finished in one sitting on a Saturday night – yes, midnight in the UK is 7 PM in Connecticut. I didn’t understand one of the answers, but fortunately it was completely checked. The next morning I looked again, and it was obvious, like so many of these puzzles. There are some obscure words in the answers, but the cryptics are very helpful, as is usual with Don’s puzzles. There are also some nice starter clues.
I have been trying to encourage some of the 15 x 15 solvers to try Mephisto – it is not nearly as hard as the Club Monthly Special, which I have never cared for. The large number of checking letters is really helpful, and enable you to analyze how the cryptic elements work – but you all know that. Tonight, I am able to offer a full and correct parsing of all the clues, but I am little puzzled by one of the literals.
Across | |
1 | A French horse stuck in turf — as one unprepared? (6) |
UNSHOD – UN + S(H)OD, a perfect starter clue. | |
5 | Talk about having church coffee party (6) |
KLATCH – TALK backwards + CH. You don’t expect to the clue to actually contain the word used in the wordplay – surpise! | |
9 | Dad, say, in amble with aged Poppy’s family (12) |
PAPAVERACEAE – PA + P(AVER)ACE + AE. I admit, I just looked it up in Chambers. | |
10 | Fish in the same place, given external supervision (6) |
CARIBE – CAR(IB.)E, where ib. is ibidem, which means….in the same place! | |
13 | Magical old sect group outside college (6) |
OCCULT – O(C)CULT, another starter clue. | |
14 | Old boy I call “deficient”, incidentally (6) |
OBITER – OB + I + TER[m], as in obiter dictum. | |
15 | Savvy, like student avoiding second drug (6) |
ASTUTE – AS + TUTE[e], with our favorite drug. | |
16 | Aid denied to oft-failed bats? (6) |
LET-OFF – Anagram of OFT-FAILED minus AID – but where is the literal? Is this an &lit? | |
18 | Explorer back after troubled rest — it may give anxiety (8) |
STRESSOR – Anagram of REST + ROSS backwards. | |
22 | Settle in part of hospital, difficult separation with wife going (8) |
ENTRENCH – ENT + [w]RENCH. | |
25 | Match with time-wasting — not the position today (6) |
FIXURE – FIX[t]URE. Fixure is a word from Shakespeare. | |
26 | Like nerve perhaps being shown by artist friend (6) |
RAMATE – RA + MATE. | |
28 | Part of insect gives different insect trouble swinging round (6) |
ANTLIA – ANT + AIL backwards. | |
30 | Aura round old tribe that is located in north Africa (6) |
AGADIR – A(GAD)IR, the tribe of Gad. Agadir is a city in Morocco. | |
31 | Fusses when soldiers come in at entrance (6) |
ADOORS – ADO(OR)S, another easy one. | |
32 | Sees nice BEd student finally excited with final certificate (12, two words) |
BENE DECESSIT – Anagram of SEES NICE BED + [studen]T. I definitely needed the crossers here. | |
33 | Workers’ guilds not initially considered in business set-ups (6) |
ARTELS – [c]ARTELS, a well-known chestnut in either direction. | |
34 | At once old bird comes to cathedral city (6) |
TITELY – TIT + ELY. |
Down | |
1 | Superior firm in history to the north by the sea? (7) |
UPCOAST – U + P(CO)AST. | |
2 | Ship’s spar gets spray? Not unknown (5) |
SPRIT – SPRIT[z]. I’ll admit, I didnt’ get this one for a long time after putting in the obvious answer. | |
3 | Arab cloth of excellent quality plunged into dye (6) |
HAIQUE – H(AI + Q)UE. | |
4 | Evil spirits parted right away after being summoned up (6) |
DEEVES – SEVE[r]ED upside down. | |
5 | African bird, last to ascent to highest point (4) |
KROO – ROOK with the K moved to to the top. I had all kinds of theories how the cryptic worked, but it turned out to be quite simple – nothing to do with K1 in the Himilayas | |
6 | Summon expert to tackle urban areas half falling apart (6) |
ACCITE – AC(CIT[ies]E. | |
7 | Foremost in the European Union with added weight — a German? (6) |
TEUTON – T[he} EU + TON, a rather apt cryptic for the Brexit crowd. | |
8 | Conservative baddy losing head — one generating lots of heat? (10) |
CALEFACTOR – C + [m]ALEFACTOR. | |
11 | Keeper of birds treasuring larks (10) |
AUSTRINGER – Anagram of TREASURING. | |
12 | Mongrel dog tribes let loose (6) |
BITSER – Anagram of TRIBES. | |
17 | Trip went wrong out of Spain with a knight trapped (6) |
ERRAND – ERR(-e,+A N)D, one that many will biff. | |
19 | Bathe, yes? Tricky without a supplier of water (7) |
BHEESTY – Anagram of B[a]THE YES. | |
20 | Old lover with blemish — not one carrying on? (6) |
EXTANT – EX + TA(i)NT. | |
21 | Monk could be secluded, not the first or last (6) |
CULDEE – Anagram of [s]ECLUDE[d]. | |
23 | Having three spiny bits or one in region of the body (6) |
TRIACT – TR(I)ACT, | |
24 | What could make most be driven to extremity once (6) |
EMBOST – Anagram of MOST BE. | |
27 | A thing growing in the garden is stemmed (5) |
AROSE – A + ROSE. This gave me a lot of trouble because I was looking for a Latinate word meaning having many stems – then I saw it. | |
29 | “Stars” would exclude one the equivalent of Mars (4) |
ARES – AR[i]ES, not a tricky anagram as you might suspect. |
On solving Mephistos, long ago I tried them a few times but didn’t make much progress so gave up. Then after a tip-off from Jim that a particular puzzle was more accessible than usual I had another go and managed to complete it, but I’m afraid deciphering obscure words from wordplay and constantly having to check my answers in a dictionary is not my idea of crossword enjoyment so I don’t feel inclined to repeat the experience. Ditto the Club Monthly – not that I have ever completed one of those.
Edited at 2021-01-03 07:09 am (UTC)