And I thought this was a very good puzzle. Nothing too abstruse bar one tribe of Israel and a bit of light maths, but tons of cunning construction, natty surfaces and humour that genuinely raised a smile.
I might have to give up on timing myself on days when I’m in sole charge of my two year old daughter – multiple pauses to queue up more Topsy & Tim on the TV, or even change a stinky bum if I’m unlucky, do not lend themselves to an accurate result – but I think this one took me in the ballpark of 20 minutes. 20A was my FOI, and all four quadrants of the grid gave me individual stiff resistance before I finished in the top left corner with 1D and 9A.
Lots of love and nothing to rail against in the construction as I say, but I think it was some of the lovely surfaces that won me over most today – 12A, 14A, 19A, 22A, 2D, 16D, 23D… I could probably go on. Even the quartet of three letter words, whose clues can tend to end up being a little throwaway, were very nicely done I thought. Kudos to today’s setter!
| Across | |
| 1 | DUFFEL BAG – grip: GABLE [Hollywood legend] “making comeback” after DUFF [not working] |
| 6 | COSEC – function: “backing group in” {offi}CE SOC{ial} |
| 9 | DARKENS – gets less light: ARK [one refuge] amongst DENS [others] |
| 10 | DRAGOON – cavalryman: D [departs] + RA{n}GOON [first knight, i.e. the first N, “to quit” capital] |
| 11 | SHEER – very much inclined: SHEAR [to make cuts] “in speech” |
| 12 | BOW-LEGGED – physically challenged: OWL [member of parliament] with BEGGED [asked] outside |
| 14 | BUT – on the other hand: T{h}U{m}B “oddly” “put back” |
| 16 | BELEAGUERED – under harassment: (BLUE + A DEGREE*) [“playing”] |
| 17 | MASTER CLASS – expert tuition: M LASS [maidens] “either side of” (CRESTA*) [“run”] |
| 19 | PLY – carry on: “those completing” {tri}P {wil}L {usuall}Y |
| 20 | GASTROPOD – “perhaps winkle”: (GOOD PARTS*) [“out”] |
| 22 | TOQUE – hat: TOE [tootsie] “eclipes” Q U [queen with posh] |
| 24 | EYEWASH – rot: E [exhibited “primarily”] + YEW ASH [a couple of tree species] |
| 26 | EMIRATE – country: E [eastern] + RIM [border “moving west”] + ETA [when we’re due “back”] |
| 27 | TITCH – “one tiny”: TWITCH [involuntary movement] – W [“on wife’s departure”] |
| 28 | SPRIGHTLY – SPRY [nimble] “without” LIGHT [nimble again] “from first to last” &lit |
| Down | |
| 1 | DODOS – old fogeys: DO’S [rules to be followed] “hosting” DO [function] |
| 2 | FERVENT – zealous: REF [whistle-blower] “taken up” + VENT [express] |
| 3 | EXECRABLE – fifth rate: EXEC [manager] + RAB{b}LE [“somewhat disheartened” crowd] |
| 4 | BASEBALL CAP – sporting headgear: (LAB PLACES*) [“mobile”] “filled by” BA [undergrad] |
| 5 | GAD – ancient Biblical tribe: “leader’s abandoned” {e}GAD [my] |
| 6 | CHAFE – cause annoyance: CAFE [diner] “swallowing” H [hard] |
| 7 | SPONGER – hanger-on: SPONGIER [giving more] – I [“ignoring” current] |
| 8 | CANADA DAY – “a time for national celebration”: CAN [john] + AD [bill] + AD [promotion] + AY [always] |
| 13 | WEAR AND TEAR – signs of age: the “contrasting water sources” being the river Wear and a teardrop |
| 14 | BE MY GUEST – please: BET [speculate] about MY GUES{S} [what I reckon, “without reaching a conclusion”] |
| 16 | UPSETTING – worrisome: UP SETTING! [“demand to increase crossword production”] |
| 18 | SUSPECT – doubt: US [you and I] “put in” {a}SPECT [appearance, without A] |
| 19 | PIQUANT – stimulating: PINT [“drink often ordered in pub”], QUA [as] “consumed” |
| 21 | ROACH – swimmer: BROACH [to bring up] – B [bachelor’s “left”] |
| 23 | ENEMY – opposition: E [“leader in” Edinburgh] + Y MEN [unknown chaps] “from south” |
| 25 | HAS – suffers from: HA’S [“surprise calls, perhaps”] |
Edited at 2014-11-28 11:48 am (UTC)
I was a bit confused by the definition at 1ac, but it turns out I was thinking of ‘clutch’, which in this context is not synonymous with ‘grip’.
I’m still a bit confused by ‘undergrad’ for BA. Isn’t the former by definition not the latter?
Agree about BA. For TOQUE I had ‘queen’=QU, with it being a posh hat, as favoured by Mary, the Dowager Queen Mother.
On the fifth day of Christmas, my true love gave to me:
5 GOLDEN TOQUES!
4 pounds of back bacon
3 french toast
2 turtlenecks
and a beer.
Just to confuse matters though, my Canadian wife just told me “oh, no, it’s definitely only ever tuque!” before suggesting that even though it sounds like tuque, it might be *spelled* toque. Sounds a bit fishy to me.
Edited at 2014-11-28 05:24 pm (UTC)
Nice to see a mini Canadian theme, with CANADA DAY and the TOQUE, which is practically national dress over there. Talking very vaguely of which, having returned to the UK this year after a decade in north America, I was really looking forward to “no more Black Friday”. Er, what happened?
Shut, shut the door, good John! fatigu’d, I said,
Tie up the knocker, say I’m sick, I’m dead.
The dog-star rages! nay ’tis past a doubt,
All Bedlam, or Parnassus, is let out:
Fire in each eye, and store cards in each hand,
They rave, acquire, and market round the land.
(apologies to Pope)
I know, I know, I’ll go and sit in old fogey’s corner where I belong, where I’ve always belonged …
Have these poor fools not heard of online shopping?
Parsing of the Year Award to cruci_fixated! Pure genius.
I still have a slight reservation about it on the basis that ‘XZ’ being synonymous with ‘YZ’ doesn’t necessarily mean that ‘X’ is synonymous with ‘Y’, but ‘slight’ is the operative word.
Having said all that, a taxi-driver I used in Burma/Myanmar was very insistent that I should avoid using the new names, which were the inventions of an unelected junta.
I found it difficult to get to grips with this puzzle, and for a long time I had only three entries in the grid. Part of the problem was some definitions that seemed slightly suspect, or at least out of kilter with normal usage, such as 12ac, 3dn (surely ‘execrable is far worse than fifth-rate), 14dn.
Then there were deceptions that were not in themselves questionable, but cumulatively added to the problems of solving, such as ‘One tiny’ for ‘Tiny one’, and ‘somewhat disheartened’ for the more usual crosswordese, half-hearted.
In the end it took an hour, with 7dn as LOI, which earns my COD for the very clever and neat use of ‘Giving more.’ As verlaine comments above, there are lots of nice surfaces throughout.
There’s a sort of neatness about this puzzle laced with some very good stuff.
I wonder if Jerry will comment about Bill in 8D after his Hamlet remarks on the Club Monthly?
I am glad to hear you are recovering from your virus, Jim, and hope you continue to thrive.
Thanks for your good wishes – the older I get longer it takes to recover from these wretched things
Edited at 2014-11-28 02:46 pm (UTC)
I finshed with the same last two as Verlaine, but not necessarily in the same order.
COD to 12 for “member of parliament” but I also enjoyed “what I reckon” for “my guess”.
* no aspersions being cast as studies show this group drives language change, not to mention many PTAs.
Edited at 2014-11-28 02:12 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2014-11-28 02:22 pm (UTC)
Thought it was another excellent puzzle with some great surfaces, particularly enjoyed 14ac.
Thanks setter and blogger.
Anyway, one man’s elm is another man’s yew, as my old gaffer used to say.
Finished in around an hour. LOI was 19 down – just after I realised that 22 was TOQUE and not TOPEE. Otherwise I’d have scribbled in POPTART and hoped for the best.
Otherwise enjoyable, but couldn’t get it all in 1 sitting so left it for a while and polished off the last few almost immediately, including correcting DUFFLE to DUFFEL – careless.
Rob