Solving time: 30 minutes. I thought I was heading for a very rare sub-20 minute solve but my last two in, 8dn and 12ac, put paid to that.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions and substitutions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]. I usually omit all reference to positional indicators unless there is a specific point that requires clarification.
| Across | |
| 1 | Distraught leaders of trade union split trophy (3,2) |
| CUT UP | |
| T{rade} U{nion} [leaders] contained by [split] CUP (trophy) | |
| 4 | Wife devoured judge in bottom section of course (5,4) |
| WATER JUMP | |
| W (wife), ATE (devoured), then J (judge) contained by [in] RUMP (bottom). The surface reading paints a gruesome picture! | |
| 9 | Management give short broadcast, making error (9) |
| OVERSIGHT | |
| Anagram [broadcast] of GIVE SHORT. We seem to have a definition at each end of the clue! | |
| 10 | View workers abandoning block of flats (5) |
| TENET | |
| TENE{men}T (block of flats) [workers – men – abandoning] | |
| 11 | Deny litter producer’s implicated in racket (6) |
| DISOWN | |
| SOW (litter producer – Oink territory) contained by [implicated in] DIN (racket) | |
| 12 | Screen translation‘s just what’s needed in Nice (8) |
| SUBTITLE | |
| IT (just what’s needed) contained by [in] SUBTLE (nice – fine). “That’s it!!”, I thought when I eventually spotted the wordplay. | |
| 14 | What windbags do best? (9) |
| UTTERMOST | |
| UTTER MOST – a cryptic hint relying on alternative spacing precedes the literal. | |
| 16 | They support members and volunteers with typing complaint? (5) |
| TARSI | |
| TA (volunteers – Territorial Army), RSI (typing complaint – Repetitive Strain Injury). Bones of the foot (member). | |
| 17 | Jack‘s last in York church body (5) |
| KNAVE | |
| {Yor}K (last), NAVE (church body – central aisle) | |
| 19 | Sense brief opening — sign on staff (5,4) |
| TENOR CLEF | |
| TENOR (sense), CLEF{t} [brief]. In musical notation clefs are signs placed at the beginning of every stave or staff (the sets of 5 lines on which notes are written) to indicate the pitch of a particular note, and hence of the other notes. They are like the key to a code, ‘clef’ being the French for ‘key’. The treble clef indicates the position of G above middle C, and the bass clef the F below middle C. The other two clefs in common use (tenor and alto) both indicate the position of middle C. The tenor clef is often used in music for cello, and the alto clef for viola. Other instruments are available. | |
| 21 | Old boy’s story involves Conservative block (8) |
| OBSTACLE | |
| OB’S (old boy’s), then TALE (story) contains [involves] C (Conservative) | |
| 22 | Drop stock complaint during trouble (6) |
| ABSEIL | |
| BSE (stock – cattle – complaint) contained by [during] AIL (trouble). ‘Bovine spongiform encephalopathy’, also known as ‘mad cow disease’. | |
| 25 | Excuse individual after jumping bail (5) |
| ALIBI | |
| Anagram [jumping] of BAIL, then 1 (individual – one) | |
| 26 | Elected party chum in Asian peninsula (9) |
| INDOCHINA | |
| IN (elected), DO (party), CHINA (chum – CRS china plate = mate) | |
| 27 | Assembly standards waiving hospital study of intake (9) |
| DIETETICS | |
| DIET (assembly – e.g. of worms), ET{h}ICS (standards) [waiving hospital – h] | |
| 28 | Now and then carpet empty library as befits it? (5) |
| APTLY | |
| {c}A{r}P{e}T [now and then], L{ibrar}Y [empty] | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Could displaced migrant settle in such a dream world? (5-6-4) |
| CLOUD-CUCKOO-LAND | |
| Anagram [displaced] of COULD, then CUCKOO (migrant), LAND (settle). I understand cuckoos don’t all migrate but some of them do to justify the description in the wordplay. | |
| 2 | Hardy girl grabbing Romeo’s hair (5) |
| TRESS | |
| TESS (Thomas Hardy girl – of the d’Urbervilles) containing [grabbing] R (Romeo – NATO alphabet) | |
| 3 | Mail was reduced regularly, primarily from late ’40s? (4-3) |
| POST-WAR | |
| POST (mail), WA{s}[reduced], R{egularly} [primarily] | |
| 4 | Carry on with period (4) |
| WAGE | |
| W (with), AGE (period). As in ‘wage war’. | |
| 5 | Old king repeatedly can start to grouch, showing pique (3-7) |
| TUT-TUTTING | |
| TUT (old king – Tutankhamun) + TUT [repeatedly], TIN (can), G{rouch} [start] | |
| 6 | Knock vale swathed in grass (3-1-3) |
| RAT-A-TAT | |
| TA-TA (vale – Latin for farewell) contained by [swathed in] RAT (grass – informer) | |
| 7 | Weird flat, perhaps, for musician? (9) |
| UNNATURAL | |
| A straight definition and a cryptic hint. More musical notation! The notes A-G are said to be ‘natural’ when not otherwise indicated as sharp or flat for example. The cryptic reading suggests that a flat is therefore ‘unnatural’. | |
| 8 | Feeble female friend absorbing current feature of lyric poetry (8,7) |
| PATHETIC FALLACY | |
| PATHETIC (feeble), F (female), ALLY (friend) containing [absorbing] AC (alternating current). I’d heard of this but had no idea what it means. SOED: the attribution of human emotion or responses to inanimate things or animals, esp. in art and literature. | |
| 13 | Wrong starter missing from film director’s pasta dish (10) |
| TORTELLINI | |
| TORT (wrong – legal), {f}ELLINI (film director) [starter missing]. La Dolce Vita is perhaps his most famous. | |
| 15 | New paintings up on top of steeple come to light (9) |
| TRANSPIRE | |
| N (new) + ART (paintings) reversed [up], then SPIRE (steeple) | |
| 18 | A short time in river Test (7) |
| EXAMINE | |
| A + MIN (short time) contained by [in] EXE (river). The Test is also a river but not the one needed here. | |
| 20 | Novel about airline carrying English cricket club (7) |
| REBECCA | |
| RE (about), then BA (airline – British Airways) containing [carrying] E (English) + CC (cricket club) | |
| 23 | Bull kept by oppressive dictator (5) |
| EDICT | |
| Hidden in [kept by] {oppressiv}E DICT{ator}. As in ‘papal bull’. | |
| 24 | Plans to exclude a date in Italy, once (4) |
| IDES | |
| IDE{a}S (plans) [exclude ‘a’] | |
Favourites were UTTERMOST and SUBTITLE (yes, good to see ‘nice’ being used in the SUBTLE sense), my LOI as well.
Thanks to Jack and setter
Elsewhere I was glad of the crossing letter for TORTELLINI which I otherwise might have thought was tortelloni. I’d like to say knowing the film director I’d have been OK anyway except I thought he was Bellini — a case of mixing my drinks and my film directors.
Then south-east, but not quite my best
Took a long time to see
PATHETIC FALLACY
But then i disposed of the rest
Which waves in every raven Tress,
Or softly lightens o’er her face;
25 mins pre-brekker, held up by the Clef, the Fallacy and Subtitle.
Lord Horryd, brekker will be Croissant with Cherry&Amaretto preserve. Hoorah.
Thanks setter and J.
Nho PATHETIC FALLACY, and wrongly guessed it was to do with the countryside.
REBECCA is a fine novel, and an excellent film, the Best Picture of 1940.
Thanks jack and setter.
Fairly quick solve. LOI pathetic fallacy.
Thanks, jack.
Confused by OVERSIGHT as did not see the anagram, and tried Oversign as a way of making an error, with Oversee (management) and Signal(broadcast) in there somehow.
For INDOCHINA, I was looking at anagrams of ‘party chum’ which looked just like anagram fodder. Kamchatka has 9 letters, and there are many other peninsulas in Arctic Russia which could have been it.
LOI TUT-TUTTING, an excellent word.
Thanks Jack and setter.
I did like vale as ‘goodbye’ in 6d as distinct from, say the Vale of Glamorgan. Clever.
Edited at 2021-06-01 09:17 am (UTC)
I’m with BW on 8dn, clearly a term derived before we knew what we now know about the animal world. And my lawn tractor is far from inanimate. More like vindictive, I’d say ..
FOI: 1a. CUT-UP
LOI: 14a. UTTERMOST
Time to Complete: DNF
In the one hour I give myself for the 15×15, I managed to answer 15 of the clues, 7 without aid, 7 with aids, and one wrong answer.
My favourite clue was 14a (UTTERMOST).
Thank you for your encouragement. I wanted to come here to see if six months experience with the QC had given me a better chance at the 15×15. I am pleased to say that it has, though I still woefully struggle here. Saying that, though, there are times when I have performed worse on the QC than I have here.
I also had a fixation trying to shoehorn a director — FELLINI maybe — somehow into FETTUCCINE which held up the difficult DIETETICS — not really aware of a diet’s relation to worms.
I had never heard of PATHETIC FALLACY until a few weeks ago when my daughter was studying for her GCSEs — PATHETIC came easily, but FALLACY took a few moments longer.
Was tempted by TENOR CLUB until I noticed the female in 8d which let everything fall into place.
Edited at 2021-06-01 05:08 pm (UTC)
– I thought I would have a quick look at this as a warm-up for the QC. I did, but kept going and finished in about 40 minutes. My last two were SUBTITLE and RAT A RAT which I had noted but couldn’t parse -so thanks for that. Somehow Pathetic Fallacy came to mind very easily.
An enjoyable puzzle. Now for the QC.
David
Edited at 2021-06-01 11:55 am (UTC)