Solving time: 1:13:12, after getting terribly bogged down in the SE corner.
I found this a bit of a hard slog. The only long one that came easily was 26. That said, the north & east sides came without too much trouble, but I then spent probably 40 minutes battling with the last 7 or 8, one of which was the anagram at 8 which took me forever to crack.
I wasn’t entirely sure about Rockall being described as a desert island. I thought a desert island had to be tropical. But having checked it in various dictionaries, a desert island is uninhabited, and usually in the tropics. So I guess it passes (but I still think it’s a little dubious).
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | AIRS + AND + GRACES |
| 9 | TALKS = K |
| 10 | ENC + HI(LA)D + A |
| 11 | OCCASIONAL = |
| 12 | D + HAL |
| 14 | A + B + STAIN |
| 16 | L |
| 17 | T(ELEC |
| 19 | OP + IN + ION – well-disguised wordplay here, ‘covered by’ = IN, ‘non-neutral article’ = ION |
| 20 | S + COW – a flat-bottomed barge. I’m sure I’ve seen this quite recently. |
| 21 | BLITHE + RING |
| 24 | KNIFE-EDGE = FEED in EG + INK rev |
| 25 | S + PAWN |
| 26 | HYPOCHONDRIAC = (A PHONY DOC RICH)* |
| Down | |
| 1 | ART FOR ARTS SAKE = O in (STAR TREK’S A FAR)* – I spent a long time trying to rearrange AESTHETIC IDEAL. Automatically makes me think of this. |
| 2 | RELI |
| 3 | AS + SI + STANCE – Another one entered without full understanding |
| 4 | DI(E)D + OWN |
| 5 | ROCK + ALL |
| 6 | C |
| 7 | SPAGHETTI = IT + (THE)* + GAPS all rev |
| 8 | HALLUCINOGENIC = (ENOUGH CLINICAL)* |
| 13 | UNLICENSED – cd |
| 15 | S(ALLOW + IS)H |
| 18 | MELODIC = MIC (singer’s equipment) about DOLE rev |
| 19 |
|
| 22 | IRAQI = I + “RAKI“ |
| 23 | Deliberately omitted – a very old chestnut |
ROCKALL seems to have captured the imagination of our setters – I’m sure this is the second time it’s appeared in a matter of days. I think the surface is fair enough, with its allusion to Desert Island Discs.
I suspected 11 was a reversed hidden word and still couldn’t find it, looking in the wrong place at first. Most of the clues were well-crafted, and if it hadn’t been for the periphery I might have struggled for quite a while.
A few of the longer ones don’t need the wordplay; I put in ‘spaghetti’, ‘opinion’, ‘melodic’ and ‘knife-edge’ from the literals alone. If I were the blogger, I would have figured them out later.
I’m not sure if this island would qualify:
“Once upon a time, on an uninhabited island on the shores of the Red Sea, there lived a Parsee from whose hat the rays of the sun were reflected in more-than-oriental splendour.”
I think the “desert” in 5D is included to make one think of the long running radio prog “Desert Island Disks”. It doesn’t quite work for me because to call ROCKALL a “desert island” is just too much of a stretch. The people of the Faroe Island would think you meant “deserted” if you tried it on them, I think. Remove the word “desert” and the clue still works, although with a weaker surface reading.
COD – I’ve got a soft spot for 16ac.
As with vinyl1 when some checking letters are in place I can often see the solution from only the definition. In this crossword I don’t think any of the definitions were very cryptic – apart from “desert island” perhaps, but even then the wordplay was very clear.
Another vote of thanks for the 10CC reminder, Dave. They and Supertramp seem to have been almost written out of pop music history. Undeservedly.
It would have been a lot quicker if I hadn’t spent at least 5 minutes staring blankly at 25ac, too focussed on finding a more literal synonym for “tool”.
COD to blithering, not keen on black liquid for ink.
Thanks for the 10cc link Dave – belting song.