Solving time : 10:51, so on the easier side, though I groaned at the cryptic definitions and shook my head at a few others. Bit of a mixed bag this one, which may mean there’s something for everyone, right? I was surprised to see the device L used for a Roman numeral in two places (leading to three L’s indicated as numbers) in the grid.
There’s even a triple-dose of cricket hiding in here.
Away we go!
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | I’m going to get the across omission out of the way early |
| 5 | BOSOMY: SO(thus),M(maiden, cricket reference #1) in BOY. Reuben always reminds me of the sketch from “Not Only, But Also” |
| 8 | ROC: first letters of Republic Of China |
| 9 | REV,ELATION |
| 10 | TREASURY: TRY around (A,RUSE)* |
| 11 | BONBON: NB(nota bene – be attentive) in BOON |
| 12 | GUYS: I think this is a reference to Guy Fawkes and Guy’s and St. Thomas’ Hospital? |
| 14 | PORT ENDING |
| 17 | MARVELLOUS: O between Andrew MARVELL and US |
| 20 | PILL: P(ounding) then ILL |
| 23 | B,ARROW |
| 24 | SHEIKDOM: (HOME,KIDS) |
| 25 | MAIDEN,HOOD: the MAIDEN is a good over and our cricket reference #2 |
| 26 | ADD: The thousand could be 500+500, so D,D Edit: I messed this up in writing the first version and had LL instead of DD |
| 27 | ADONIS: take the first letters away from sAD,sON,hIS |
| 28 | SNOWFALL: NOW in S,FALL(baseball playoffs are also known as the “fall classic”) |
| Down | |
| 1 | STRATAGEM: (START,GAME)* |
| 2 | ARCHERY: Cricket #3 – the new ball in cricket is called A CHERRY, so move one of the R’s to the top |
| 3 | HERE’S,Y: Y being the end of conformitY |
| 4 | LIVERPOOL: R in a game of LIVE POOL |
| 5 | B,RAMBLE |
| 6 | SKINNY-DIP: cryptic definition |
| 7 | M,ON(playing),SOON |
| 13 | SOVEREIGN: take IT from SOVIET REIGN |
| 15 | TOUCH(just a little),DOWN(depressed) |
| 16 | let’s leave this out of the downs |
| 18 | A,L,ARMED: another Roman numeral making an appearance in L |
| 19 |
|
| 21 | INDIANA: DIANA is the female hunter succeeding IN |
| 22 | WINDOW: N in WIDOW(partner, after loss) |
ALL doesn’t fit my answer for 16dn at least.
Not hard, but enjoyable. The three that stood out for me were HERESY, BONBON and GUYS, which is my COD as, besides seahorses, I also have a soft spot for 4-letter clues.
How could I have missed “good over” (=MAIDEN) at 25ac? And why, more perplexingly, did I want VIRGINHOOD?
SNOWFALL: I had no idea that “fall” was a baseball season and just assumed that our baseballer was a metonymic American.
ROC: don’t think there’s a need for “originally”. I have far too many labels in the house reading “Made in ROC”.
COD to the &lit (HERESY).
I’d be surprised if everyone knows the reference at 1ac to the tongue-twister “She sells sea-shells on the sea-shore” so I thought I’d mention it.
As I have already pointed out elsewhere, 25ac only works from the point of view of the bowler. The batsmen who are “In” would not count a maiden over as a “good” one.
I suspect ‘baseball player’ at 28 was intended to indicate nothing more than the American use of ‘Fall’ as a season of the year.
ROC at 8ac comes from ‘1001 Arabian Nights’.
Edited at 2012-03-15 06:58 am (UTC)
Oh, and congrats on beating McTight!
Edited at 2012-03-15 08:07 am (UTC)
You may be right about ‘over’ but I would expect a commentator to say, for example: ‘he had a good over’ or something else that identifies the POV from which it’s expressed. Not being a cricket follower I’m not sure that a maiden over can be judged as intrinsically good per se as it might be the result of the incompetence of the batsmen. However, an ace in tennis is different because it’s unreturnable.
Edited at 2012-03-15 08:48 am (UTC)
What price NYT: FALL = “cricketer’s autumn” anyone?
(JerryW, on a channel ferry)
A quick solve today helped by some easy constructs (B+arrow, Rev+elation, Port+ending, A+l+armed, (F)lawless), simple anagrams (Stratagem, Sheikdom, Gold Medal) and plain definitions. Made a careless mistake at the end with Snowball not Snowfall. D’oh!
20 minutes which is about as fast as I get. LOI Guys. You’re right about the Guy Fawkes, Guy’s teaching hospital reference George. I’m glad there was only one unchecked letter – not sure I’d have got it from say G?Y? or ?U?S. Thought this one might cause problems for non-UK solvers.
Cherry for new ball raised a smile.
Will today be the day that sircharrington completes his first puzzle?!
Edited at 2012-03-15 10:27 pm (UTC)
It’s not that long ago that I finished my first Times puzzle without any help (11 June 2007) and I’m now completing one in four and 80%+ on most days. I usually find that if I get completely stuck then putting the puzzle down for an hour and coming back to it fresh soon gives another answer or two. It’s amazing how my subconscious works away on the clues in the interim and how when I revisit the puzzle thoughts occur to me that didn’t the first time.
I wasn’t sure what “old” was doing in the clue for BARROW, but I see Chambers has it as obs, except in place names. Curious.
Like others, I assumed baseball player was there to give the American flavour, Any hope of cricketer’s fall sometime?
All decent, neat and tidy clues, with GUYS my laconic CoD.
(And I know it’s always dangerous to try to discern a pattern in these things, but does this run of three easier puzzles after a ticklish one on Monday portend a real stinker tomorrow?)
Tomorrow may be a different story!
LOI: BONBON: COD: HERESY
COD.. PORTENDING … puntastic.
I’m with ulaca on “good over” = MAIDEN. Any ascription of goodness comes from a certain point of view, but here there’s a clear default, because an over is tied to a given bowler (barring e.g. sudden injury, I suppose, though I don’t know what the protocol is for continuation afterwards) in a way that it’s not tied to a given batsman. Of course, a batsman might be said to have had a good over, just as a commentator might; but I think it’s fair for a setter to treat a good over tout court as one that’s good from the bowler’s point of view.
Roger
Ugly, but arguable?