After a very tough puzzle from Pedro on Friday – it took me 16 minutes, way over my 10 minute target – we have another tricky one today from Izetti. This took me 13 minutes which at least didn’t count as another trip into my my ‘red’ zone of 15+ minutes, and it was very enjoyable so I don’t begrudge the extra time spent on it. On reflection, many of the clues were straightforward and they provided checkers to assist with the more difficult ones.
Only one clue is perhaps a little out of the range of GK to be expected of the average QC solver. I dredged the answer from somewhere only because I studied that period of history about 55 years ago and remembered the name, though not the detail of the affair which the clue alludes to.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions and substitutions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]. I usually omit all reference to positional indicators unless there is a specific point that requires clarification.
| Across | |
| 1 | Awful singer to pack it in (6) |
| RESIGN : Anagram [awful] of SINGER | |
| 4 | Change hands after turning around (4) |
| SWAP : PAWS (hands) reversed [turning around] | |
| 9 | Lose vitality being awfully liverish when one passes out (7) |
| SHRIVEL : Anagram [awfully] of L{i}VERISH [when one – i – passes out] | |
| 10 | Artist and fashion designer not finishing off set (5) |
| RADIO : RA (artist – Royal Academician), DIO{r} (fashion designer) [not finishing off]. ‘Set’ in this context has come up before and gave rise to queries from those of younger generations. In the old days of cat’s whiskers and valves, radio and TV receivers were known as ‘sets’. | |
| 11 | Layabouts sitting around trees — quality of uncomfortable ground? (9) |
| BUMPINESS : BUMS (layabouts) containing [sitting around] PINES (trees) | |
| 12 | You and I possessing nothing — misery (3) |
| WOE : WE (you and I) containing [possessing] 0 (nothing) | |
| 13 | Unhappy about housing everyone in US city (6) |
| DALLAS : SAD (unhappy) reversed [about] containing [housing] ALL (everyone) | |
| 15 | Son was worried, frightened (6) |
| SCARED : S (son), CARED (worried – I don’t care about that) | |
| 17 | Fellow from east side of capital city (3) |
| DON : {lon}DON (capital city) [east side of…]. A self-reference by the setter here! | |
| 18 | School finally not able to provide dining facility for its staff? (4,5) |
| HIGH TABLE : HIGH (school), {no}T [finally], ABLE | |
| 21 | Earlier head of religious order (5) |
| PRIOR : Two meanings | |
| 22 | Escape quietly with undergarment removed (4,3) |
| SLIP OFF : SLIP (undergarment), OFF (removed) | |
| 23 | Clothes from stores ultimately got sent back (4) |
| TOGS : {store}S [ultimately] + GOT all reversed [sent back] | |
| 24 | Odd trees containing good birds (6) |
| EGRETS : Anagram [odd] of TREES containing G (good) | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Girl and American pal making bloomer (7) |
| ROSEBUD : ROSE (girl), BUD (American pal ) | |
| 2 | Go away from academic room in the morning (5) |
| SCRAM : SCR (academic room – Senior Common Room), AM (in the morning). There’s something of the cloistered world of Academia about today’s puzzle, what with SCR here and ‘High Table’ in another answer! | |
| 3 | Live with a girl almost out of control? See if that works! (4,2,1,5) |
| GIVE IT A WHIRL : Anagram [out of control] of LIVE WITH A GIR{l} [almost]. A somewhat saucy surface. | |
| 5 | Wife and I rowed terribly? My wife’s now gone (7) |
| WIDOWER : W (wife), I, anagram [terribly] of ROWED | |
| 6 | Quietly put on attire for exploration (5) |
| PROBE : P (quietly – musical direction), ROBE (put on attire) | |
| 7 | Expression of surprise about learner showing mirth (4) |
| GLEE : GEE (expression of surprise) containing [about] L (learner) | |
| 8 | Hurry to obtain caustic extract from newspaper (5,7) |
| PRESS CUTTING : PRESS (hurry to obtain – can I press you on that?), CUTTING (caustic) | |
| 14 | Part of a flight or the end of one? (7) |
| LANDING : Two meanings, re staircases and aeronautics | |
| 16 | One falsely imprisoned doctor you upset — endless commotion (7) |
| DREYFUS : DR (doctor), then YE (you) reversed [upset], FUS{s} (commotion) [endless]. Tough stuff for a QC. Solvers feeling in need of a history lesson can read all about it here. | |
| 17 | Dorothy keeps record in storehouse (5) |
| DEPOT : DOT (Dorothy) contains [keeps] EP (record – Extended Play). More outdated technology. | |
| 19 | My journey ends with request for silence (4) |
| GOSH : GO (journey), SH (request for silence). ‘My!’ is more usually ‘Cor!’ so this makes a nice change. | |
| 20 | Beer and suchlike? You may hear shouts of disapproval (5) |
| BOOZE : Sounds like [you may hear] “boos” (shouts of disapproval) | |
I have been offered the opportunity to dine at an Oxford high table on two occasions quite recently and turned both down. Not my scene at all, and I went off port years ago.
Edited at 2020-12-07 05:56 am (UTC)
But I had a meal at High Table when I received my MA (circa ‘81) and went back to the OCR and learnt more about the true essence of academia in that session than I did in three years as an undergraduate. Thanks for the thought Kevin.
Edited at 2020-12-07 09:11 am (UTC)
Average QC solvers are not necessarily lacking in GK. We are just learning to negotiate Crosswordese.
Edited at 2020-12-07 10:59 am (UTC)
FOI 1ac RESIGN
LOI 7dn GLEE – I will never be asked to join this club.
COD 11ac BUMPINESS – assembled with IKEAN pine.
I note Kane’s sled appears once again at 1dn.
‘So often the early comments here are not representative..’. America First!
Edited at 2020-12-07 08:38 am (UTC)
No, I meant that the earlier posters (and I count myself amongst them) tend to be very experienced solvers of cryptic puzzles so they (sorry, we) may give the impression that everything is easy or, in today’s case, common knowledge. A different picture tends to emerge as more people with varied experience of cryptics contribute throughout the day.
Edited at 2020-12-07 09:20 am (UTC)
I would advise dear Mr. Wyvern that there are more productive ways of wasting an hour. Your daily struggles make for heroic copy, but why not take up pianoforte, horticulture or marquetry? I do jams and philately which are most rewarding pastimes and avoids my attendance at the Club Monthly Special, which is a complete waste of my time – as are ‘Jigsaw Puzzles’ and pilates. Meldrew
Thanks to Jack
FOI: 3d GIVE IT A WHIRL – I was about 18 minutes in before I got the first one in.
LOI: 22a SLIP OFF
30 minute mark: 6 answered
60 minute mark: 17 answered
Time before use of aids time: 38 minutes.
Once I got my FOI, I started to do much better.
14d I was sure I had seen that clue fairly recently before.
I spent too much time ,oozing for an anagram of SON WAS in 15a.
Not a bad start to the week for me, but I do hope I’ll improve as the week goes on.
One piece of advice may be never to spend long on any individual clue, especially in the early stages; there are sure to be easier pickings elsewhere in the grid. But having made a start, focus your attention for a while on the adjoining clues and try to build from there. If you are stuck abandon that and look elsewhere. A fresh look at a clue, even after only a couple of minutes can sometimes make all the difference.
Edited at 2020-12-07 10:55 am (UTC)
At all events stick at it – it doesn’t matter how long it’s currently taking you, if you enjoy it that’s all that matters. And you will, as Jack says, get suddenly quicker one day when it all comes together. Just like learning to drive really – clutch down, move gear-lever slowly to next position, clutch up again slowly. And then one day, bang!, you don’t even realise you’re doing it 🙂
H
1a actually went in easily for me – anagram of singer – I actually wrote in Swop before realising that it had to be Swap.. Son is often just S but maybe not!!
Anyway – keep going !!! And keep your progress coming! I was as you and am now around the 15/25 minutes with approx 80% completed.
From this blog you learn the basic language and will definitely improve no end with practice! But enjoy all and expect a few that set you back to thinking that you are a total novice even after a few years!!!
Regards
John
Knew Zola’s J’Accuse regarding the Dreyfus affair.
FOI Resign
LOI Bumpiness
COD Slip Off
Reading the blog realised I had not gone back and fully parsed Don.
Thanks Izetti and Jack
DNK “Dreyfus” but it was accessible from the clueing and it became fairly apparent it was probably some name or other I hadn’t heard of as part of my limited GK. However, the trickiest ones for me we’re 10ac “Radio” and 6dn “Probe”. I nearly put “Place” for the latter.
Lots to like though, including 11ac “Bumpiness”, 18ac “High Table” and 5dn “Widower”.
FOI – 12ac “Woe”
LOI – 6dn “Probe”
COD – 14dn “Landing”
Thanks as usual.
As ever Izetti’s clueing was very precise; a help for beginners. COD to DALLAS but other candidates too.
David
2 Down:
“Go away from academic room in the morning (5)
SCRAM : SCR (academic room – Senior Common Room), AM (in the morning).”
Senior Common Room ? Really ? Do you need to have been to a public school to do these crosswords ?
16 Down:
“One falsely imprisoned doctor you upset — endless commotion (7)
DREYFUS : DR (doctor), then YE (you) reversed [upset], FUS{s} (commotion) [endless].”
YE ? Really ? Are we all talking like Biblical prophets now ?
We seem to have more days of toughies than easy write ins. Not a bad thing for some – but perhaps straying away from the original intention of introducing new people to cryptics and/or providing something accessible that can be completed “quickly”.
Cedric
I’m not complaining, unlike like some miserable specimens (usually anonymous, of course) who whine at length when it a crossword is not tailored specifically to them. I enjoy these challenges and there were certainly some lovely clues today (but I won’t list them). Clues like SCRAM only came into my head when I got crossers, despite being a SCR member for decades; I think some solvers think that every clue has to be solved as a stand-alone. Some of us rather depend on building up the crossers as we jump around the grid!
Many thanks to Izetti for a challenge and jackkt for the blog. John M.
Edited at 2020-12-07 11:26 am (UTC)
Why do I have to think to complete a cryptic puzzle, why? Too hard, ridiculous, why can’t they all be write ins?
It’s the “Quick” cryptic, not “Easy” cryptic. I don’t think I have ever finished the 15×15 in less time than the QC. I normally complete the QC in 5-10 mins, 5 being an easy puzzle, 10+ being hard. 15×15 in 15-60 minutes. So I think it is not disingenuous to call it the “Quick” cryptic. I’ve been doing these things for 15 years, and it was more than 2 years before I could finish a 15×15 unaided, there being no QC when I started.
The crossers are a massive help, which is why I just move on to the next clue if nothing springs to mind immediately. E.g. SHRIVEL today – I could see it was an anagram of liverish, minus an i, but couldn’t think of it, so left it, and came back to it, whereupon it was a write in, given the crossers. Same with HIGH TABLE, no clue on first pass, though with TABLE in the back of my mind as “dining facility”, when I come back, I have H?G?/T?B??, then it’s no great leap to put in HIGH TABLE, I suppose it could be HUGE TABLE, but HUGE has no relation to “school” in the clue.
FOI – 1ac RESIGN
LOI – 16dn DREYFUS
COD – 5dn WIDOWER
Was no-one tempted with Bruce Forsysth’s catch phrase of “Give us a Twirl”?
Is BUMS for layabouts British English? I thought in the UK it only meant backside.
I recently read the Robert Harris book, but did nor rate it highly. Harris is better with pure fiction IMHO.
No problem with GK such as Dreyfus, but I dislike the over preponderance of Public School & Oxbridge vocab that we solvers are expected to know. After ETON FIVES a couple of weeks ago, we had DON, SCR and HIGH TABLE today.
COD: SLIP OFF
Otherwise, I didn’t struggle as much as I usually do with Izetti.
LOI. Radio (COD) and Probe (confess I looked up that one). Also liked Booze.
As I said, I knew Dreyfus. Got Depot but couldn’t parse EP. Must remember that one. Guessed Scram from AM. Did not think of SCR.
Thanks, blogger, and also many thanks for weekend QC, Phil.
Edited at 2020-12-07 12:43 pm (UTC)
COD – PAWS
If anybody fancies pushing themselves, try the Saturday Prize 15×15 – quite doable I found.
H
PLEASE, a little less clubby.
We do not need to have spent time in business, in hospital, in the motor trade or whatever to be able to consider terms used in such areas. The same is true for every other area from Geography to literature and music.
I’m always happy to have my horizons broadened by terms discovered via Crosswords. 🙂
Edited at 2020-12-07 12:45 pm (UTC)
I am learning to be not surprised these days when a puzzle takes me a little longer than expected – this one took me 16 minutes, against my long run average for Izetti of just under 14. But unlike some puzzles I have struggled with recently, this one was never an unenjoyable experience with some very good clues and some nice touches. My LOI was the much-mentioned 16D Dreyfus, which only fell after all the checkers and then considerable thought: to those of a certain age or reading interests, Dreyfus is not particularly obscure GK, but I think the combination of a foreign name (always potentially difficult) and some very intricate construction in the clue did mark it out as quite challenging for a QC. But if setters were not allowed to set any clues requiring just a little cogitation the enjoyment would be much reduced.
I also thought a bit at the time about Cared = Worried in 15A; the two are not really synonyms but I put it in anyway and can convince myself they are close enough.
I suspect more experienced solvers have seen it before, but COD for me the very simple 4A Swap: a nice clue and a most elegant surface.
Many thanks Jack for the blog
Cedric
The QC has this range, only with reduced obscurity. Dreyfus, but not Leon Blum, ye but not uncer, bevy but not cete, earl but not eorl, etc, etc.
I Liked PAWS, BUMPINESS.
6:31 for me.
I suspect I will never get on with izetti I just don’t like his style of clueing. But in the words of Sinatra “that’s life”
FOI: resign
LOI: gosh
COD: give it a whirl (which is wHt we should have done with 18A)
Thanks Jackkt.
Bucking the trend somewhat, I found that a Monday breeze which I knocked off in 1.4K over a bowl of soup.
FOI RESIGN, LOI GLEE (“gee” is so American that it took a long time to come to mind), COD GIVE IT A WHIRL (lovely), time a Very Good Day.
Many thanks Izetti and Jack.
Templar
It’s Christmas maybe a little more charity to those who struggle on the puzzles
Still anon.
If you are unable to sign up for a free Live Journal account (or for some reason don’t wish to) you can follow the example of some of our regular ‘anons’ and add a name or pseudonym at the end of your contributions to give yourself a form of identity. That way we get to recognise you and can make you feel welcome.
I managed to do all bar one in 2 Rotters which is my target having also watched the snooker. Johnny
No problems in seeing this off within my time limit.
EGRETS ? I have a few, but, then again, too few to mention….
FOI SWAP
LOI HIGH TABLE
COD WIDOWER
TIME 4:27
But thank you very much, bloggers, for all your help and patience. I’ll probably stay in the Slowcoach Club but I do often finish nowadays.
I don’t know if the Crossword editor reads the blog but I hope so.
Surprised to read that quite a few had never heard of Dreyfus since he came up last week in a QC (French author, Zola, J’Accuse). A very defining episode in French politics, national press, anti semitism, the judicial system and the power of the public voice. A gripping read.
And now to tomorrow.
Thanks everyone.
As to the QC, DNF. It was 7d GLEE which was the problem. When I read the blog, it was less “Aha!” more “Doh!” So it went.