Well, one thing this puzzle wasn’t, for me, was boring. it took me over half an hour, nearer to forty minutes, because I was led off in the wrong direction a couple of times and side-tracked into Wiki and Collins to learn more about things I was hoping were correct. It’s my kind of puzzle; you come away pleased to have finished it but sad that it’s over.
The astronomer I had heard of, the Cornish river too (from memories of childhood holidays), and the Latin bits I knew. The ‘little darling’ flower I had to construct from its fodder but it then rang a bell. The 2d and 9a crossers were my LOI and I liked the French food to chew on.
The astronomer I had heard of, the Cornish river too (from memories of childhood holidays), and the Latin bits I knew. The ‘little darling’ flower I had to construct from its fodder but it then rang a bell. The 2d and 9a crossers were my LOI and I liked the French food to chew on.
| Across | |
| 1 | Servant‘s goodbye coming with retirement finally (5) |
| VALET – VALE = Latin for goodbye, T = end of retirement. | |
| 4 | Poet taking time around end of autumn to find wild animal’s domain (4,5) |
| HOME RANGE – HOMER is our poet, add N (end of autumn) put into AGE (time). | |
| 9 | Leaving the City area — it’s stifling outside (9) |
| DECAMPING – I had trouble with this, as for a while I had a T as third letter from 2d pencilled in wrongly. City area is EC (as in City of London), inserted into DAMPING which can mean stifling, shutting down, nothing to do with warm weather. | |
| 10 | London giant’s journey featured in periodical (5) |
| MAGOG – GO (journey) inside MAG = periodical. I wrote it on because I knew Gog and Magog were giants in the Bible, but I didn’t know what they had to do with London. Now I do, read about it here if you didn’t know either. | |
| 11 | Something attractive about holy person? (6) |
| LUSTRE – ST (saint) inside LURE (something attractive). I’ve made the whole clue the definition as otherwise ‘something attractive’ has to do double duty. | |
| 12 | It’s all right to interrupt one funny person or another (8) |
| JOKESTER – JESTER is one fully person, if you insert OK you get another. | |
| 14 | Religiously committed school entertaining archdeacon with a set of holy books (10) |
| COVENANTED – a school could be CO-ED, into that insert VEN for archdeacon and A NT for a, set of holy books. | |
| 16 | Good wood is cut (4) |
| GASH – G for good, ASH a kind of wood. | |
| 19 | Session spanning winter months (4) |
| TERM – hidden as above. | |
| 20 | Running late, trains can pose a problem? (10) |
| TANTALISER – (LATE TRAINS)*. | |
| 22 | Female performance promises to be divisive (8) |
| FACTIOUS – F (female) ACT (performance) IOUS (promises to pay). There’s factious, and fractious, which mean almost the same but not quite. | |
| 23 | What’s crazy in a French female — and maybe divine? (6) |
| UNMADE – I wanted this to mean crazy, at first, but the definition is ‘maybe divine’, i.e. not made by man, so UNMADE; MAD for crazy goes inside UNE being the French feminine article. I suppose you could stretch feminine UNE to mean a female person. Perhaps you could say “combien des femmes soient ici? Une.” but it wouldn’t be nice French as I learnt it. “Une seule” perhaps. | |
| 26 | Fare to get across lake or swamp (5) |
| FLOOD – FOOD is fare, insert L for lake; I think here swamp is a verb, as a swamp isn’t a flood. | |
| 27 | Barge in season, heading off south east, beyond river (9) |
| INTERPOSE – (W)INTER, PO (the river) SE. | |
| 28 | Spooner’s sentimentality, something sweet providing inducement (4,5) |
| HUSH MONEY – Dr Spooner was saying MUSH HONEY being sentimentality and something sweet. | |
| 29 | Exhausted author lying in street (5) |
| SPENT – PEN (author, as a verb) inside ST(reet). | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Devious devil, one sort of agent briefly turning to wit (9) |
| VIDELICET – (DEVIL)*, I (one) TEC (agent) reversed. VIDELICET is short for videre licet which is Latin for ‘permitted to see’ and often shortened to viz; meaning ‘that is to say’ or ‘to wit’. | |
| 2 | Wants to be sluggish, first to last (5) |
| LACKS – well, SLACK = sluggish, move the S to the end. I began with SLOTH becoming LOTHS, but then got stuck with 9a, until I tried another route. | |
| 3 | Tree in delta below river (8) |
| TAMARIND – The delightful River TAMAR forms much of the border between Devon and Cornwall. Add IN and D for delta. | |
| 4 | Hotel dealt with trouble, bringing acclaim (4) |
| HAIL – H for hotel, AIL for trouble. | |
| 5 | Get men into reorganising plant (10) |
| MIGNONETTE – (GET MEN INTO)*. The mignonette is a pretty flowering plant, native to the Mediterranean area, it means ‘little darling’ in French. | |
| 6 | A politician in socialist hue rushed around violently (6) |
| RAMPED – A M.P. inside RED. Collins has “RAMP; 6. (esp. of animals) to rush around in an excited manner. As our new dog Ted3 seems to do most of the time. | |
| 7 | Drinks late on? They won’t help you keep a cool head then (9) |
| NIGHTCAPS – whimsical cryptic definition. | |
| 8 | Wholehearted bore needing an audience (5) |
| EAGER – my best effort so far is to presume eager sounds like auger, meaning bore, but I can’t make them sound very alike. EDIT Kevingregg tells us below:an EAGRE is a tidal bore, and so a homophone, I didn’t know that. | |
| 13 | Said annual travelling around should be in part of Spain (10) |
| ANDALUSIAN – (SAID ANNUAL)*. | |
| 15 | Savage — time to oust one, right? (9) |
| VERACIOUS – savage = VICIOUS, replace I by ERA for time. | |
| 17 | Food in France perhaps a mother’s cooked, full of energy (9) |
| HORSEMEAT – (A MOTHER’S)* with E dropped in. Horsemeat is indeed available in most French hypermarkets; I’ve never tried it, mainly because it’s about three times the price of beef and I don’t eat much red meat. I would eat it if I was given it, just as I would with venison, but preferably not in a Tesco beefburger. | |
| 18 | Plain folk from the south irked, note, with everyone (8) |
| LLANEROS – from the south = reversed; SORE (irked) N (note) ALL. A herder in S. America, so named after the llanos or plain grasslands in Spanish. | |
| 21 | Is daughter given order to follow women’s good sense? (6) |
| WISDOM – W(omen) IS D(aughter) OM (order of merit). | |
| 22 | Garbage left abandoned staff finally collected in interval (5) |
| FIFTH – FILTH = garbage, delete L and insert F the end of staff. Interval as in music. | |
| 24 | Residence of a German man of law (5) |
| ABODE – you could biff this if you didn’t know that Johannes BODE (1747-1826) had a famous Law dealing with the relative mean distances between the sun and its planets. | |
| 25 | Maybe lost dog has run away for stick (4) |
| STAY – lost dog = STRAY, take away R for run. | |
Perhaps the moral of the story is: when ya got it, biff it.
FOI 1ac VALET – I miss valet parking.
(LOI) 24adn ABODE – BODE was perhaps the first German Dr. Who.
COD 17dn HORSEMEAT. I have partaken on several occasions – horsemeat was eaten widely during both World Wars – it was available on ration in Huntingdon, when I was a nipper.
I have had ‘cavallo carpaccio’ at Agnelli’s Golf Club in Turin, and have noted a dedicated butchery in Emilia Romagna which fooled my father-in-law.
WOD 5dn MIGNONETTE – aussi un bouquet garni
The French may be open to eating viande de cheval, but they like to be told at least before they bite into it, as was seen in the fraud scandal of 2013.
Thanks to setter and blogger
Quite liked it nevertheless. We used to draw Bode plots in control systems to test they were stable – not the same Bode, according to Wiki.
The river Tamar is, of course, in Tasmania.
30’23”
One clue I was never going to understand was 15dn because I had the wrong answer – settling for VORACIOUS. With hindsight I was aware that VERACIOUS also exists but I’m not sure their similarity had ever occurred to me before. I note that this would seem to be the first appearance of VERACIOUS in a 15×15 in the TfTT era, although it did occur once in a Jumbo, last year, since I started solving them every week.
Edited at 2021-06-02 06:22 am (UTC)
Edited at 2021-06-02 07:03 am (UTC)
Veracious – never heard of it. Went for voracious = savage, natch, but couldn’t parse that. Nonetheless, on I swam, straight into the keepnet. Good misdirection. Tough old bird, this puzzle. Bode was new to me too.
Thanks, pip.
35 mins.
What Jackkt said.
Thanks setter and Pip
Edited at 2021-06-02 07:28 am (UTC)
I will continue to plod my way though these 15×15.
Completed the QC though.
Thank you (and Kevin) for explaining ABODE, UNMADE and EAGER.
LOI was LLANEROS. I spent too long trying to find a word that began ALL….
The Llaneros (good name for a Welsh Doo-Wop group) had me beat, but I had biffed VORACIOUS so was doomed anyway. Tant pis.
Thanks to Pip and the setter.
‘sont’ (not sure why the subjunctive here?)
Point taken about ‘une’, though.
Forgive the pedantry
keriothe isn’t a tantaliser a term people use for some intractable puzzle, where the solution is almost there but not quite?
Very unsure about UNMADE. All I could think of was an unmade bed, which is hardly divine.
Edited at 2021-06-02 10:14 am (UTC)
Edited at 2021-06-02 04:51 pm (UTC)
I have received a puzzle of the ‘Pigs in Clover’ kind… ‘Penning the Lambs’ is the name by which the latest variation of the original tantalizer has been christened
Of course you might describe a puzzle as a tantaliser, but you might equally describe it as a frustrater. I can’t see any evidence of general usage in this sense.
Edited at 2021-06-02 06:40 pm (UTC)
How is a TANTALISER a problem?
I read 11ac as an &Lit and a reference to a saint’s halo.
Edited at 2021-06-02 09:50 am (UTC)
I don’t see why a halo is particularly attractive, on a saint or otherwise. But I agree the whole clue is the definition.
NHO MIGNONETTE but seemed an obvious anagram, was overthinking HORSEMEAT until the penny dropped. No problem with MAGOG. Also had FEROCIOUS for a while.
Thanks setter and Pip
About 2/3 completed today.
COD JOKESTER
Edited at 2021-06-02 11:16 am (UTC)
99% of the population have little or no Latin, so while VALE(T) might be guessable, I doubt that many know of VIDELICET. It’s bad enough battling random plants, random Latin is no better.
Edited at 2021-06-02 06:44 pm (UTC)
I can’t find any statistics on Latin knowledge penetration in UK, but I’d dispute your 1%, given 600,000 kids are in independent schools, a falling number, out of about 8 million, and almost all of those will receive Latin as a subject, optional or mandatory. And perhaps more, 35 years ago when you were in school. You also need a good deal of specialised Latin to do the Law, and there are plenty of lawyers!
Edited at 2021-06-02 11:17 pm (UTC)
I didn’t say 1%, but your argument that Latin is OK because it’s taught in independent schools rather makes my point for me. The setters and editors are alienating the 93% of the population (including me, but not my daughter) who don’t go to these schools, which I think is unwise, and (I hope) not intentional.
I’m not arguing for the complete exclusion of Latin, by the way. One of the things I love about these puzzles is the fact that you learn things from them, whether that be Latin terms, the names of obscure plants, books of the bible or whatever. For me it’s a question of balance: remember your (especially younger) audience, keep it in check, and above all make the wordplay clear!
The wordplay was helpful throughout so I trusted it to learn new words and meanings. The best enjoyment from crosswords.
I’ve never seen JOKESTER anywhere, DNK the usage of RAMPED, and the German scientist was well outside my boundaries of interest. I knew of the llano, so LLANERO was workable. I managed not to screw up the spelling of VIDELICET (it wouldn’t have been the first time).
FOI VALET
LOI LUSTRE (with a shrug)
COD HUSH MONEY
TIME 11:02
With a clue that I’ll cherish forever
For this Astro-nut knowed
Of the law due to Bode
Our setter’s most awfully clever
Only heard of Magog from the name of the Cambridge Golf Club “Gog & Magog”
Fortunately changed 15d to Veracious just before submitting.
My COD 28 ac “Hush Money” simply because I saw the Spoonerism immediately which is seldom the case normally.
Thanks to Pip for an entertaining blog and to setter.
Accidentally saw the average time before starting (23 mins apparently) so assumed it was an easy one and was cursing my sluggishness
No problems with UNMADE — straight in and VIDELICET worked out from w/p
I did Latin and Greek A level but entirely agree that a lack of knowledge of them makes this crossword less accessible which is a shame. My kids asked to do the Guardian Quiptic rather than the QC this week on the basis it’s a bit more up to date and they raced through it. Might have a problem bringing them back from the dark side 😀
Thanks all