This is the second of the six crosswords used in the preliminary stages of the recent Championships. Peter B is on holiday at present, but he has left us some comments:
“Prelim 1 Puzzle 2: I started this one at the same speed as Puzzle 1, but came to a halt in the SW corner, mainly from being unable to answer the question “Why Mack with a K?” at 4 down. When answered (I’m sure the tune was on my iPod waiting for use after handing in my puzzles), others like 26, 28 17 and 19 fell quite quickly. Other source of delay and mystery: trying to find wordplay for AVOCET in 28. Maybe 10 minutes, in two chunks – Puzzle 3 was done as a way of re-jigging some brain cells while stuck. 10A was the other trap I was thinking of when discussing last Wednesday’s 19A.”
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | vivacity – exam = VIVA + CITY, a “great place” |
| 5 | Cannae – a homophone, or thereabouts. .. for “canny.” and also Scots for “can’t.” Sorry if that was not clear Cannae was one of the battles where the Carthaginian general Hannibal demonstrated his exceptional tactical abilities |
| 9 | – deliberately omitted.. ask if unsure |
| 10 | uninhabited – not self-conscious = UNINHIBITED, with the I being removed and replaced with A to make UNINHABITED – a fine clue, this one, elegant surface and tricky underneath.. easy to get caught out, as Peter says |
| 12 | cricket bat – two fliers, = CRICKET + BAT, the result being used for, eg, a leg glance.. |
| 13 | fair – F(A)IR as in “a fair size” |
| 15 | clutch – 2 defs. |
| 16 | rankled – road = RD containing ANKLE = joint |
| 18 | outback – blooming = OUT + BACK = “in the past” |
| 20 | stifle – ELF + ITS, rev. My second last in, I was convince the fairy was contained inside “it” or alternatively was outside another word that meant to strangle. I first thought of “skilla,” a word for fairy that sadly does not exist.. |
| 23 | ward – WAR + D, to give custody in the “ward of court” sense |
| 24 | Micronesia – (INCOMER IS A)* Another fine clue; beautiful anagram, beautiful surface |
| 26 | raw material – artist = RA + (LAW I)* containing mother = MATER. I had a bit of trouble unravelling the wordplay, though the answer was clear enough |
| 27 | – deliberately omitted.. think duvet |
| 28 | dunlin – debt collector = DUN + NIL rev. To my inexpert eye a dunlin’s beak looks as straight as a die, unlike an avocet’s but what do I know? |
| 29 | stubborn – (BOB TURNS)* ..another elegant surface |
| Down | |
| 1 | Venice – V(E)NICE |
| 2 | vitriol – V + I + TRIO + L, the V, I & L being our old friends, Roman numerals |
| 3 | chuck steak – CHUCKS + TEAK |
| 4 | twist the knife – cheat = TWIST, + THE KNIFE as in Mack The Knife. I had a lot of fun choosing the link here, do try a couple of other versions too if you have the time. Though I doubt if this tune would end up on my ipod. If I had one. |
| 6 |
asbo – |
| 7 | – surely this one doesn’t need an explanation? |
| 8 | Eldorado – (LOADED)* containing gold = OR |
| 11 | head restraint – (STARTED HERNIA)* .. another fine surface reading and my COD, I think! |
| 14 | indian club – orient = INDIAN + CLUB = “footballers maybe.” Would “oriental” be better? ..no it wouldn’t, the reference being to Leyton Orient, a club based in East London; thanks to Fathippy |
| 17 | hot-wired – employed = HIRED containing OT + E , the def. being “started probably illegally.” |
| 19 | throw in – a reference to the worlds of boxing (“throw in the towel”) and association football apparently, both something of a closed book to me but even I knew that when the ball leaves the pitch a throw-in is a normal result |
| 21 | lesotho – “for fear” = LEST containing O, + house = HO |
| 22 | bang on – 2 defs. |
| 25 |
Bali – I thought of party = a do, etc, I thought of party as in “third party,” but even though BALI was a strong candidate for the last space left in my grid, it took me forever to see party = LAB |
That said – i had never heard of Indian Clubs, so struggled with this one, having to run through the letters one by one… ENSIGN CLUB anyone ??
Just wondering if there will be North-of-the-border complaints about the homophone at 5ac. Does nae bother me.
And 12ac reminded me of the Yorkshireman who asked where bats go in winter. “I don’t know, but if you don’t oil ’em, they crack”.
“I just received an email about the possibility to renew my subscription when it expires next year (Do I honestly want to put myself through another year of battling with the Listener?) and clicked the link. It didn’t work and I emailed the customer service. An instant, most courteous reply came back, saying that they were having a problem with the link that will be fixed within an hour. Things do seem to be looking up.”
I note they don’t advise when the new subscription actually starts and finishes so in view of previous hassle over renewals I have written asking for confirmation in writing.
I believe we are all supposed to get an additional month free of charge before the new sub starts and I’ve an idea I was also offered some extra days as compensation for some cock-up or other they made over my renewal last time.
You’ve got to watch them as they are quite capable of taking the money twice.
I’m VERY angry that the Times have messed around yet again with the appearance of the puzzle when printed in grey (the lines of the grid are now in heavy black which is distracting and it wastes ink). Also for the first time for me it didn’t print on one page when using the default font size which seems to be point 14.
draft. This provides a decent-sized grid with quite readable clues, lots of space to
work things out in and a traditional black-square puzzle without using a lot of ink.
I also prefer solving using black ink with a bottle of correction fluid close at hand.
The overall effect is quite pleasing to the eye with a feeling akin to ‘oatmeal you can stand on’.
Got 5A CANNAE from the “battle” and “Scots can’t”, ignored the homophone. I liked 10A, UNINHABITED – a very slippery clue that forces one to read carefully. I think bar crossword solvers will have known DUN=debt collecting but I don’t recall seeing DUNLIN before, so quite obscure really
Speaking of bar crosswords I’ve won a prize for Mephisto 2615, the first I’ve ever won for any Times crossword – so still running behind Barry!
Excellent news Jimbo.
Also, the font choices are such that the smallest is near microscopic and the next size up (the default) is larger than necessary. Neither matches yesterday’s take it or leave it font which, for me, was fine.
Mike O
Skiathos
I have reported this in the General forum without much hope, but perhaps if many people do this they just might put in a quick fix.
Otherwise I made very heavy weather of this. I didn’t help myself by writing SCREW THE KNIFE, immediately realising it was wrong, then confidently writing CHICKEN in at 12ac. Again I immediately realised this was not just wrong but daft, but at this point the NW was a bit of a mess. Somehow it’s hard to ignore letters in the grid even when you know they’re wrong and I had more trouble than necessary with 1ac and 10ac as a result.
More haste, less speed.
INDIAN CLUBS have appeared somewhere very recently: if not here then in a jumbo or the FT.
Nick M
So that’s 2 out of 2 all finished and correct for me so far, although I’m already over the hour (just)!
As the clock ticked towards the hour I just stared at 28, deciding that however likely it was that there was a debt collector called Dan, Den or Don in Hardy, Austen or Trollope, Dunlin sounded more like a bird so that’s what I went with, holding up my number with about 1½ minutes to spare.
cheers
cheers
Joe
And an ASBO is an Anti Social Behaviour Order. Wiki says it’s “a civil order made against a person who has been shown, on the balance of evidence, to have engaged in anti-social behaviour” – so can we award one to the developers of the new site, please?
Having done a lot of Brecht at school, Mack the Knife sprung to mind immediately.
overall, another tough but enjoyable qualifier (he says with the benefit of hindsight…). My favourite clue? CRICKET BAT due to two non-avian fliers and a great definition.