Solving time: None recorded.
I was way too tired to attempt this puzzle before going to bed, but I knew I wouldn’t have a chance to blog it otherwise, so attempt it I did. I got about half of it done in an hour, but I was more asleep than awake. I could barely read the clues, let alone solve them! I took the dog for a half-hour walk to get some fresh air, then polished it off in another ten minutes or so.
I’m on jury service all this week and next, so I’ll probably be unable to respond to comments until the evening.
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | PARASOL = PARAS + LO rev |
| 5 | ELBOWS – I got this from the checkers, but I didn’t understand the wordplay. |
| 8 | A + POLO + GIST |
| 9 | OGLES – rev hidden in |
| 11 | HOBBY – dd |
| 12 | BETTER OFF – dd |
| 13 | RE + STRICT |
| 15 | PRE |
| 17 | THIN + G |
| 19 | CONCERTI = CONCER |
| 22 | GALATIANS = GALA + (SAINT)* |
| 23 | PO |
| 24 | THREW = “THROUGH” |
| 25 | MAR(GAR)INE |
| 26 | BAR + YON |
| 27 | EVEN |
| Down | |
| 1 | PLAY + HARD TO GET |
| 2 | RHOMBUS = (O + M) in (SHRUB)* |
| 3 | STORY – The American spelling of STOREY. |
| 4 | LAID BACK = DIAL rev + BACK |
| 5 | E + STATE |
| 6 | BIOMETRIC = (MICROBE + IT)* |
| 7 | WALDORF = ROD in FLAW all rev |
| 10 | SOFT-BOILED EGG = (BIGGEST OLD FOE)* |
| 14 | RIGHT AWAY = RIGHT WAY about A |
| 16 | CON’S + TRUE |
| 18 | ILLYRIA = ILL + AIRY rev |
| 20 | ROSSINI = OS + SIN in |
| 21 | B + ATMAN |
| 23 | PLANE = dd |
On edit (and a visit to Oxford online), an elbow can be ‘a thing resembling an elbow, in particular a piece of piping bent through an angle: a cross-fitting with elbows and straight pipework‘, which might be close enough.
Edited at 2012-01-20 06:26 am (UTC)
58 minutes for me on this one, with the unknown BARYON in last, after I’d got BATMAN from the literal, ‘atman’ being unknown to one with no pantheistic leanings.
I thought I was on for a sub-30 minute when the left-hand side shot in, but it took ROSSINI and then PREFAB (I was working around —ACE, i.e. ‘palace’) on the right to fall before I gained a foothold there. Some sort of improvement, as I got the reverse hidden near the end rather than at the end.
I thought the puzzle was pretty good, but I don’t like solving online. I need a pencil to cross out letters in anagrams.
I read the ELBOW clue as referring to the raising of a glass while out on a bender (as in ‘binge’). I’m sure there are idioms along the lines of ‘bending your elbow’ for ‘having a drink’ but I can’t bring any to mind.
loved PLAY HARD TO GET and CONSTRUE
Thanks, Dave, and good luck with jury service (whatever you do don’t tell them you’re a well-known blogger or you might be discharged on the spot and that would just be rotten luck).
Edited at 2012-01-20 02:55 am (UTC)
Then I solved 2dn and before I knew it the LH side apart from 26ac was in place. RH proved a bit more difficult but I finished in 44 minutes which didn’t seem too bad after such a slow start.
I didn’t ‘get’ ELBOWS (and still don’t really despite the suggestions above) nor POSSE exactly – POSE with the S of ‘sheriff’ included rather than deleted. Can’t see a definition so I guess it’s &lit? Is YON clued by ‘that’ in 26ac?
Edited at 2012-01-20 05:37 am (UTC)
As for ELBOW, see my latest theory above.
As for ELBOWS, I’m not sure I’m any further down the road to understanding. The suggestions presented all seem pretty weak. That’s not to say they’re not correct, of course, it may well just be a weak clue. But I still feel I’m missing something clever.
Anyway, must get on. I can’t be late for my deliberations!
The difference in size and font between the first two alternatives (extra small and gigantic) of the online print version certainly irritates me.
I found this puzzle mildly irritating. Religious references always irk me a little: there’s nothing wrong with them intrinsically, but like plant names they put me on the defensive. Combined with this there are some things in here that I found a bit loose, such as:
> In 26ac BARYON the “hidden” seems superfluous. It misdirects but without contributing anything else to the clue
> “Like a salad” for WALDORF: a “Waldorf” IS a salad. It doesn’t really describe it. “Like a tower” for EIFFEL?
> 27ac contains a basic error. What imitates a bird, as any fule kno, is Superman. See also “what imitates plane”
And like others I didn’t understand ELBOW. Sotira’s explanation seems the most likely to me.
Sotira’s take on 5ac is the intended one, I think.
While solving, bending the elbow as an activity while on a bender seemed the most likely explanation (like “the raising of the wrist”) but the bit of plumbing suggested by sotira looks pretty good.
POSSE has to be an &lit, but it’s not a very good one.
Loved both long ones, 1 for the wordplay, 10 for the definition. Joint CoD’s
It seems perfectly clear to me that Sotira’s reading of ELBOWS is correct.
Nicely balanced puzzle this.. one science, one music, one biblical…
Isn’t 25ac a beautiful clue?
I’m in the booze-up club for ELBOWS but think as a clue it’s pants.
Another trip down memory lane with PREFAB. After WW11 they were erected on Tooting Common as a “temporary measure” and were still there decades later long after the wartime allotments had gone. They were quite pleasant dwellings.
Edited at 2012-01-20 10:11 am (UTC)
NOT
…always one pesky clue that defeats me! I must be jinxed. This time it was the (unknown) BARYON (technically, I guess it’s only half a clue I didn’t get, as I had the BAR bit… ). However, I must admit, it could’ve been two: BATMAN could have quite easily gone in as ‘barman’.
Best wishes for the weekend, everyone, see you all next week.
Finally, I loved Jimbo’s use of the word pants to describe 5a. I remember that it wasn’t so long ago that a spleen was vented in Dorset when pants was used as an anagram indicator.
Andy B
Enigma
Some years ago I got put on the Manhattan homicide grand jury (in other words we decided whether to indict) for 4 long weeks. The saying is that the DA can get the grand jury to indict a ham sandwich. Actually I’m pleased to say we were were quite independent. I had My Big Book of Daily Crosswords to pass the time (the setting was way too distracting for anything more taxing). The biggest daily distraction was when the inmates arrived around 11am from Rikers Island – the holding pen. We all learned some new words.
Oh, I suppose the idea is that in flying a plane imitates a bird-? Copying the dynamics? seems thin.
Edited at 2012-01-20 05:38 pm (UTC)
Anyway, 9:33 here, but with the whole of the top half in after 3:24 (when I was interrupted by a long phone call), I was hoping for much quicker. The bottom half was a bit trickier for me though, but I didn’t know that until I went back to it several hours later.
Thanks for this, Andy. Brilliant as usual!
Edited at 2012-01-21 12:01 am (UTC)
Thanks Dave for a good effort under the circumstances. Pets do make a significant impact on our lives…
http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2012/01/20/christie-blatchford-stephen-harper-missed-the-boat-on-cows-inmates-and-lessons-in-tenderness/
Still, all is forgiven with the smile-raising 1D
JB
And I’m looking forward to ‘In praise of shorter clues’, Tony. Do mention on these pages when you have that one written. I’m sure it will draw plenty of interest (and debate).