A solving time of 32 minutes, and a puzzle requiring some thought. Lots of playfulness in both definitions and wordplay, which I find to be something which tends to divide the solving community; most of the time I liked it, even if I raised an occasional metaphorical eyebrow.
With Jumbos I generally confine myself to discussion of answers which I think might be a) less straightforward for inexperienced or non-UK based solvers, or b) especially elegant / questionable. However, as always, if a particular clue is not discussed, please feel free to raise it in comments for explanation or discussion.
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 6 | FINE LEG – (FEELING)*; the obligatory cricket reference to weed out the non-Commonwealth / non-sporting solvers early on. |
| 13 | BUSINESS CLASS – cryptic double def.; anecdotally, turning left on boarding an aircraft means you’re going into first or business class; I turned left the last time I boarded an aircraft, but it was because I was boarding at the back of a Ryan Air plane, and I would be exaggerating to describe the experience as first class. |
| 14 |
TRANSLATE – TRA |
| 16 | BOSWELL – (SOB)rev. + “WELL!”; Doctor Johnson’s companion and scribe. |
| 17 |
DULLEST – DULLES + T |
| 18 |
ANTICLERICAL – |
| 24 | SIEGFRIED – (IS)rev. + E.G. + FRIED; a hero of Scandinavian mythology and 20 across. |
| 26 | POTTING SHED – POTTING (as in snooker balls) + SHED (=dropped). |
| 30 | RUBBER STAMP – i.e. a single item of deskware, which could also be broken down into a rubber (Americans will note the potential for hilarity arising from the British term for an eraser) and a stamp. |
| 34 |
WALLOON – W |
| 36 | RECTANGLE – REC. (i.e. Recreation Ground) + TANGLE. |
| 38 |
ARLES – |
| 41 | TOP OF THE POPS – TV pop music programme which, though now defunct, will presumably be familiar to all British solvers, less so to non-Brits. |
| 45 | DIGESTS =”DI JESTS”. |
| 47 | BREATHE – (B-HEATER)*; I wasn’t convinced that “breathing” something necessarily indicates intensity (indeed, my instinct was that it suggests softness) but it can, so the definition is fair, I guess. |
| 49 |
FALL ABOUT – FALLA + B |
| 50 | CLOSED CIRCUIT – CLOSED (=not working) + CIRCUIT (=lap). Obviously this is right, but I hesitated with the idea of “closed” equating to “not working”; still not totally convinced… |
| 52 | DUPLE – sliceD UP LEft. |
| 53 | KIDNEYS – (YEN)rev. in KIDS; nice cryptic def. in “they strain their bodies”. |
| 54 | ADOPTABLE – ADO + P + TABLE (=dummy); parsing will take longer than solving if you aren’t familiar with games such as contract bridge, where a player uses cards from a dummy hand which is laid out by his partner – playing from these can be referred to as playing from the table. |
| Down | |
| 2 | MOSQUITO NET – [OS + QUIT] in MONET. |
| 3 | LINDA – (A.D. NIL) all rev. |
| 5 |
TIC – TIC |
| 6 |
FLAGSTAFF – [LAGS T |
| 7 |
NESTED – [TSE- |
| 11 | TRADE SECRET – TRADE(=deal with) SECRET(=hidden); I have vague memories of something called Tips and Wrinkles, a newspaper column perhaps? |
| 12 | OVERT – 0 + VERT (green in heraldry). |
| 16 | BRIDESHEAD REVISITED – cryptic def. picturing a bride having a new veil applied; to be picky, I’d say that the book is very much Charles’ story, not Sebastian’s. However, I suppose the idea was to give a broader hint to people who might be less familiar with the characters, and might have more of a penny-drop from Sebastian. |
| 21 |
ASPARAGUS – A S |
| 23 | TOP DRAWER – (WARDEPORT)*. |
| 25 |
DE MILLE – (MED |
| 27 | DEPICT – “the way to empty early Scotland once” would be to de-Pict it. To remember who the Picts were, I always refer to Sellar and Yeatman, viz. “The Scots (originally Irish, but by now Scotch) were at this time inhabiting Ireland, having driven the Irish (Picts) out of Scotland; while the Picts (originally Scots) were now Irish (living in brackets) and vice versa. It is essential to keep these distinctions clearly in mind (and verce visa).” I hope this makes it clear. |
| 29 | MANDATE – i.e. a date with a man; Bridget Jones is a fictional character, m’lud, famous for her comic diaries in which she describes her atempts to lose weight and find a marriageable man. I suspect that if you are the sort of solver who doesn’t like playful whimsy, this is the clue you’ll find most annoying. |
| 31 | BULLDOG CLIP – (British) BULLDOG + CLIP(=speed). |
| 35 | ON MESSAGE – (MENSO)* + SAGE; what all modern politicians are expected to be. |
| 37 |
ANOMALOUS – A NO |
| 42 |
TOBACCO – (CABOT)rev. + CO |
| 44 |
FESCUE – S |
| 45 |
DYFED – F |
| 48 | EGRET – E.G. RET (one of those very crosswordy words, meaning to soak a crop). |
| 51 | ETA =”EATER”. |
Like you, I’m not convinced by CLOSED = “not working” in 50ac. And, as you say, BRIDESHEAD REVISITED is definitely Charles’s story rather than Sebastian’s – I’d have thought that would have been obvious to the setter even if s/he’d only watched the TV series!
I clearly haven’t travelled on the right sort of planes (or perhaps I’m just naturally unobservant), as I could have sworn that, on pretty well every plane I’ve ever boarded, turning left at the top of the stairs would have landed me in the cockpit.
I was reasonably happy with parsing 14ac – taking “stop” = “to withhold” (or something similar) – but not with 24ac, which seems to have FRIED = “(to) be electrocuted” – that is, unless there’s some other way of using “be”. If not, then the wordplay seems to lead to SIEGFRY.
And (pace Sellar and Yeatman), I’m not convinced that “de-Picting” Scotland wouldn’t have left a whole bunch of Scots there.
Edited at 2012-03-13 11:28 pm (UTC)