Solving Time: Well, I solved it on the day, over a month ago now, and can’t remember how long it took but doing the blog now, it seems reasonably straightforward. My answer sheet is completely clean, usually a sign of a quickish solve. This is the third of the crosswords in the second preliminary round and so, presumably we now bid goodbye to this year’s Championship, the Grand Final efforts having been published already. Taken as a set of nine I think they demonstrate quite clearly why The Times cryptic is still the one that sets the standard.
cd = cryptic definition, dd = double definition, rev = reversed, anagrams are *(–).
ODO means the Oxford Dictionaries Online
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 |
unwise – |
| 4 | Caucasus – A + S in CAUCUS. The Caucusus region is notable for being either in Europe or not, depending on who you ask. As such it may/may not contain Europe’s highest mountain, Mt Elbrus. It so happens that I flew past the Caucusus on Monday, my way back from Qatar and a fine sight they are too, even from 35,000 ft. |
| 10 | dishonest – DISH + ON + *(SET) |
| 11 |
sonar – |
| 12 |
tie – TIE |
| 13 | have ones way – sport with = HAVE + ON, + E + SWAY = influence. Clever clue! |
| 14 | barrow – BAR ROW. Grave = barrow, along with dolmen, eolith, megalith, cromlech, menhir etc etc. all appear now and again, also see 2dn. |
| 16 |
sloe gin – *(G |
| 19 | oddball – a cd referring to snooker, the values of the balls mentioned being 1, 3, 5, 7. |
| 20 | apeman – appellation = NAME + PA = progenitor, all rev. The def. being an &lit. |
| 22 | egalitarian – *(ANTI REGALIA), and another &lit too. |
| 25 |
eel – |
| 26 |
eagle – E + A |
| 27 | ownership – OWN + ER + SHIP |
| 28 | pilaster – only remaining = LAST in support for bridge = PIER. A pilaster is a flattened column added to a wall for decorative or aesthetic purposes |
| 29 | red top – “read” + first = TOP. It is a matter for national shame, that they find so many daily buyers as they do. |
| Down | |
| 1 | update – finished = UP + DATE. Up as in “Once the snake struck home, it was all up with him” etc. Or, “time’s up” if you are a bit less fanciful |
| 2 | wasteland – standing stone = STELA (aka stele) in WAN + D. I like the picture the clue conjures up |
| 3 | sloth – SLOT + H |
| 5 | action stations – has influence = ACTION on ranks = STATIONS, in the sense of what you must not act above.. I’m less sure in what sense “action” is the same as “has influence”, however |
| 6 | casserole – turkey = ASS in *(CREOLE) |
| 7 | sinew – function = SINE + W |
| 8 | straying – runs = R in STAYING. Has there ever been a Times cryptic with no cricket references whatsoever, I wonder? |
| 9 | leave well alone – a dd, one referring to well = bore (hole) |
| 15 |
readiness – “book within presses centrally” = READ IN |
| 17 | grapeshot – G + RAPE’S + HOT. Shotgun pellets for artillery, sort of. |
| 18 | home help – in = HOME + HELP = aid |
| 21 | slip-up – another cricketing reference, the SLIP being the classy fielder close to and behind the bat, ready to catch an edged shot. |
| 23 | angel – A + N + GEL. Theatrical angels invest in new plays. A risky business, since the opportunity to back sure-fire hits is normally restricted to friends, colleagues etc. See The Producers for the opposite process, ie finding investors for a sure-fire flop |
| 24 |
nerve – NER |
On 5dn, I think it’s ‘influence’ as in ‘force’ = ‘action’ and ‘has’ is not part of the definition.
Edited at 2012-11-28 01:29 am (UTC)
‘Odd’ for the snooker balls seems a bit of stretch to me. Apart from that, good puzzle. COD to DISHONEST; thanks to setter and blogger.
I think Jerry’s explanation is, how shall I put it?, better than the clue itself.
Edited at 2012-11-28 09:09 am (UTC)
One small suggestion: I suspect that ‘sport’ = ‘have on’ in the sense of ‘wear’, and that the ‘with’ really is a connector. It does seem to work either way, but I didn’t like the first interpretation.
4ac reminded me of the joke about the difference between a caucus and a cactus. (With particular ref to the Australian Labor Party.)
As I’d already done this, had a go at Saturday’s about which there’s been much talk here, and which I’d missed at the weekend. All I can report is that instead of recording the time, I wrote a detailed expletive.
As it unfolded afresh, I remembered thinking that this was the most interesting and innovative of the three offerings, with some clever cluing. ODDBALL raised a smile, EGALITARIAN a fine &lit and discovered anagram, UNWISE prompting all the wrong responses (backwards? enclose an A? look for a word meaning leader?), SLOE GIN a smooth and elegant surface. Perhaps the nearest thing to a “normal” crossword experience in the adrenalin fuelled, speed inspired atmosphere of competition.
A decent challenge and a delight, and as Jerry says, demonstrating why it’s the Times that sets the standard.
I had the same thought about 11ac, and I’m not happy with the idea that what bats have is sonar, whatever Chambers says. However the clue says “ability like a bat’s”, so it doesn’t matter.
Like jackkt I thought “action” was “influence” and “has” is just a filler.
I thought “have on” was “sport”, but it works either way.
And I just read the snooker clue as “every other” ball, without thinking about the points. If I was asked to name them in order I’d do so from red up to black. When you’re playing cards you don’t necessarily play the jack before the queen but that’s still the order you’d put them in.
As for 11ac, if it said “porpoises” instead of bats it would have been bang on, if a rather harder clue.
But as you say it doesn’t really matter. Neither clue was hard to solve correctly, which I tend to see as the main thing
The problem I have with “sonar” for bats (and porpoises) is the use of a name for a man-made system to describe a natural phenomenon. I realise the dictionaries are all against me on this!
Edited at 2012-11-28 11:18 am (UTC)
Edited at 2012-11-28 05:36 pm (UTC)
ac. ‘Oddball’ is stretching it (in my view scoring value) but it’s the sort of stretch that eases into a grimace of acceptance I guess. Having last entered the preliminary round of the competition in about 1970 it’s this sort of experience that tells me to leave well alone.
I suspect this is one of the setters whose wavelength I have difficulty with. There were one or two clues I liked, but there were too many where I had difficulty matching some part of the clue to the part of the answer it was clearly supposed to match.